Mansion House

Hotel in Vineyard Haven

With 48 rooms, Mansion House is a little big to be termed 'boutique,' but it's got a lot of personality and owners who care. The fresh citrus tones and the balconies appeal, plus there's an on-site spa and fitness center (the latter is free to guests). The icing on the cake is the rooftop deck with panoramic harbor views.

It has ecofriendly policies, and some rooms are pet-friendly.