Pauly's Cafe

Italian in Cumberland Island & St Marys

On the main intersection in St Marys, this friendly, chintzy cafe serves big sandwiches to go, with a side of either potato salad or pasta. Plus, it does a good selection of Italian pasta dishes – carbonara, tortellini and chicken parmigiana, spinach lasagne and more. The tiny interior with bookshelves filled with trinkets is a little dingy for dining in, however.