American in North Fork & Shelter Island

North Fork Table & Inn

A favorite foodies' escape, this four-room inn (rooms from $250) has an excellent farm-to-table restaurant, run by alums of the esteemed Manhattan restaurant Gramercy Tavern. Dinner is served Thursday to Monday, but…
Mexican in North Fork & Shelter Island


The Mexican-wrestler theme dominates the pink-and-blue walls, but that's not the only reason young and old alike flock to Lucharito's agave-tinted dreamscape. There's a list of tequilas longer than your arm, daily f…
American in North Fork & Shelter Island

Love Lane Kitchen

At this popular place on a cute street, local meat and vegetables drive the global-diner menu: burgers, of course, plus spicy chickpeas and duck tagine.
Seafood in North Fork & Shelter Island


A Greenport legend, owned by the Portuguese Claudio family since 1870. For a more casual meal, hit Claudio's Clam Bar on the nearby pier.
Desserts in North Fork & Shelter Island

Four & Twenty Blackbirds

An outpost of the Brooklyn pie experts, with delectable fruit and chocolate varieties.