Restaurants

Top Choice Cafe in Nantucket Town

Corner Table

A real local gathering place, this sweet cafe has great coffee, a cabinet full of high-quality eats to eat in or takeaway (black bean and sweet potato salad, chicken ragu with pasta, mascarpone raspberry cheesecake)…
Top Choice Modern American in Nantucket Town

Proprietors

Creative, globally inspired cooking and fine cocktails go down a treat here, at this bar-restaurant that proudly flaunts local farm-to-table fare. Your eyes may be bigger than your belly when reading the small-plate…
Top Choice Modern American in Nantucket Town

Company of the Cauldron

A splendid choice for a romantic dinner out, this intimate restaurant has attentive service and top-rated food. It offers only reserved seating times and four-course prix-fixe dinners, with the likes of rosemary-ske…
Top Choice Market in South Shore

Bartlett's Farm

From a humble farm stand this family operation has grown into a huge gourmet market, with salads, tempting desserts and sandwiches (including a great lobster roll). It's the perfect place to grab everything you'll n…
Seafood in Nantucket Town

Straight Wharf Restaurant

The best place for fresh-caught seafood served up with a harbor view is the deck of this hot restaurant featuring New American fare. Start with iced oysters with lemon granita, then move on to the restaurant's very …
International in Nantucket Town

Lola 41°

We tip our hat to anywhere beloved by locals for both burgers and high-grade sushi. Lola 41° is named after Nantucket's latitude, and the menu borrows from others along that parallel, including Spain, Italy and, esp…
Barbecue in Nantucket Town

B-ACK Yard BBQ

Taking inspiration from the South, but wrapping it in a New England sensibility, BYB 'only smokes the good stuff.' Clam chowder comes with smoked bacon, mac 'n' cheese comes with lobster. Meats by the half-pound inc…
Modern American in Nantucket Town

Black-Eyed Susan's

It's hard to find anyone who doesn't adore this petite, long-running, quietly gourmet place. At breakfast, try the sourdough French toast topped with cinnamon pecans and orange butter; at dinner, sit at the bar to w…
Pub Food in Nantucket Town

Brotherhood of Thieves

A longtime favorite of locals, who come for the friendly tavern atmosphere (set off with brick and dark woods) and some of the island's best burgers. Not in a burger mood? How about a fish burrito made with local co…
Cafe in Nantucket Town

Centre Street Bistro

Settle in at a parasol-shaded sidewalk table and watch the traffic trickle by at this relaxed, year-round cafe. The chef-owners, trained at the Culinary Institute of America, make everything from scratch, including …