Restaurants

Top Choice Seafood in Montauk

Clam Bar at Napeague

You won't get fresher seafood or a saltier waitstaff, and holy mackerel, those lobster rolls are good, even if you choke a bit on the price. Three decades in business – the public has spoken – with cash only, of cou…
Seafood in Montauk

The Dock

Absolutely no bullshit allowed: signs warn away cell phone users and families with screaming children. The unique decor includes stuffed animal heads and waterfowl, carnival masks, and a totem pole. The hearty red M…
Bistro in Montauk

Tauk

The original roadhouse bar is still here, as is a urinal from Grand Central Station circa 1916 (thankfully inside the men's room). Some Montaukers have taken the reins, giving it a firmer local identity and more rea…
Seafood in Montauk

Westlake Fish House

In the marina of the same name, this is a great place for seafood, all caught the same day. Chef Larry Kolar has been recognized by fellow chefs in the rankings of Best Chefs America, and among his favorite dishes i…
Seafood in Montauk

Lobster Roll

'Lunch' is the sign to look for on the roadside west of Montauk, marking this clam-and-lobster shack that has been in operation since 1965. It's now infamous as the liaison site in the Showtime television series The…