Top Choice Pizza in Middlebury

American Flatbread

In a cavernous marble-block building with a blazing fire that keeps things cozy in winter, this is one of Middlebury's most beloved eateries. The menu is limited to farm-fresh salads and custom-made flatbreads (don'…
International in Middlebury

51 Main

Overlooking Otter Creek, this high-ceilinged restaurant, lounge and live-music venue was started by a few Middlebury College students as a fun social space where people could dine, perform and generally hang out. It…
Bakery in Middlebury

Middlebury Bagel & Deli

Since 1979, the Rubright family has been showing up at 4am daily to bake some of New England's finest doughnuts and bagels. Skiers on their way to the slopes, workers en route to the job site and professors headed f…
Cafe in Middlebury

Storm Cafe

In the basement of Frog Hollow Mill, this creekside cafe serves breakfast, followed by soups, salads and sandwiches at lunchtime. In good weather, the more substantial dinner offerings are best enjoyed out on the te…
Burgers in Middlebury

A&W Drive-in

For a slice of retro Americana, stop at Middlebury's A&W Drive-In. Among the few remaining New England branches of this century-old national chain, it's the only one where carhops on roller skates still deliver …
Bakery in Middlebury

Otter Creek Bakery

This bakery, with some outdoor seating, is popular for takeout pastries, strong coffee and creative sandwiches. Traveling with a pooch? It'll lick your face if you buy it an Otter Creek dog biscuit.