Restaurants

Pizza in Big Pine Key, Bahia Honda Key & Looe Key

No Name Pub

The No Name’s one of those off-the-track places that everyone seems to know about. Despite the isolated location, folks come from all over to this divey spot to add their dollar bills to the walls, drink locally bre…
Modern American in Sugarloaf Key & Boca Chica Key

Square Grouper

One of the most talked-about restaurants in the Keys, Square Grouper hits all the right notes with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, innovative recipes and great service, all dished up in one elegant but unpretent…
Cafe in Sugarloaf Key & Boca Chica Key

Baby’s Coffee

This very cool coffee counter has an on-site bean-roasting plant and sells bags of the aromatic stuff along with excellent hot and cold java brews – many locals consider this to be some of the best coffee in the isl…
Vegetarian in Big Pine Key, Bahia Honda Key & Looe Key

Good Food Conspiracy

Rejoice health-food lovers: all the greens, sprouts, herbs and tofu you’ve been dreaming about during that long, fried-food-studded drive down the Overseas Hwy are available at this friendly little macrobiotic organ…
Diner in Big Pine Key, Bahia Honda Key & Looe Key

Coco’s Kitchen

Enter through the nondescript storefront into this tiny luncheonette, where local fishers join shoppers from the Winn Dixie next door for diner fare and local gossip. Serves a good mix of American standards and Cuba…
Caribbean in Sugarloaf Key & Boca Chica Key

Mangrove Mama’s

This groovy roadside eatery serves Caribbean-inspired seafood – coconut shrimp, plantain-crusted hogfish, cracked conch sandwiches – best enjoyed on the backyard patio and accompanied by a little live music (daily f…