Hayley's Motel

Motel in Sarasota Keys

Owner-operated Hayley's offers motel rooms, one-bedroom suites and buckets of 1950s charm. Super-quaint and competitively priced for Anna Maria. You'll find it about a block back from Holmes Beach. There's a $50 fee for pets, though they aren't allowed in high season (February to April) and the beaches on Anna Maria don't allow dogs.