Top ChoiceBreakfast in Pine Island

Perfect Cup

A genuine local gathering place, Perfect Cup offers just that: a bottomless mug of flavorful house-roasted coffee ($2) to go with its top-quality diner-style fare – creative omelets, French toast and pancakes.

Seafood in Pine Island

Island Seafood Market

This lime-green shack offers a great selection of fresh seafood to cook, as well as succulent grouper sandwiches, crab cakes and chowder for lunch.