Top ChoiceSeafood in Islamorada

Lazy Days

One of Islamorada's culinary icons, Lazy Days has a stellar reputation for its fresh seafood plates. Start off with a conch chowder topped with a little sherry (provided), before moving on to a decadent hogfish...

Mexican in Islamorada

Bad Boy Burrito

Tucked away in a tiny plaza among a gurgling fountain, orchids and swaying palms, Bad Boy Burrito whips up superb fish tacos and its namesake burritos – with quality ingredients (skirt steak, duck confit,...

American in Islamorada

Bayside Gourmet

This stylish, modern, but very friendly deli and restaurant is a family-run affair and feels quite a step up from the average Keys seafood shack. The diverse menu serves up something for all palates, from...

American in Islamorada

Beach Cafe at Morada Bay

The Beach Cafe has a lot going for it, namely a lovely, laid-back Caribbean vibe, a powder-white sandy beach, nighttime torches, tapas and fresh seafood. It's also a good place to bring the kids, with room to run...

Cafe in Islamorada

Midway Cafe

A homey cafe that is a favourite stopover on the journey to the Keys for its excellent coffee and good sandwiches, wraps, salads and omelets. The lovely folks who run this cafe roast their own beans and make...

American in Islamorada

Lorelei

Need a sunset and some excellent seafood? This lovely open-sided spot over the water has got you covered. The sunsets really are magnificent, an experience compounded by good fish or cracked conch sandwiches,...

French in Islamorada

Pierre’s

For a decadent night out, head to this two-story waterfront plantation, which has some of the best cooking between Miami and Key West. Start off with some Peruvian-style ceviche or fresh oysters, then move on to...

Cafe in Islamorada

Bob’s Bunz

The service at this cute cafe is energetic and friendly in an only-in-America kinda way, and the food is fine, filling and cheap. Key lime pie is a classic Keys dish and key lime anything at this bakery is highly...

Seafood in Islamorada

Island Grill

The ramshackle waterfront building may not look like much, but you'll be surprised by how tasty the peel-and-eat shrimp and conch fritters are. Casual, contemporary Floribbean fare with breezy ocean views and...