American in Sandusky

New Sandusky Fish Co

This hole-in-the-wall spot on the bay is terrific for lake perch and walleye sandwiches with a side of French fries. The fish are caught daily and swaddled in crunchy breading. There are no indoor seats, so head out…
Pub Food in Kelleys Island

Village Pump

Grab a table or a stool at the bar in this old-school tavern, a good spot to tuck into fried perch, lobster chowder and burgers. A chocolatey Brandy Alexander, the house-special cocktail, is a fine way to sop it up.