American in Cumberland Island & St Marys


Right next to the Riverside Cafe and opposite the Visitor Center, this simple cafe serves up unpretentious American classics: burgers, steak sandwiches, chili cheese fries and hotdogs, plus wraps and sandwiches. The…
Italian in Cumberland Island & St Marys

Pauly's Cafe

On the main intersection in St Marys, this friendly, chintzy cafe serves big sandwiches to go, with a side of either potato salad or pasta. Plus, it does a good selection of Italian pasta dishes – carbonara, tortell…
Greek in Cumberland Island & St Marys

Riverside Cafe

A Greek cafe that does a take on the gyro: pork, lamb or beef are seasoned and pounded into gyro-like strips (it doesn't have a rotisserie), piled with lettuce, feta and tzatziki, and folded into a fresh pita. There…
Cafe in Cumberland Island & St Marys

Cedar Oak Cafe

Small cubbyhole cafe serving reasonably priced breakfasts, plus sandwiches and bagels for your Cumberland Island trip. You can't go wrong with the grilled tuna with salad, onion, tomato and Swiss on rye bread.