Top Choice American in Narrowsburg


A slice of Brooklyn on the Delaware, the Heron has reclaimed wood picnic tables, tin ceilings and a refined menu touting locavore credentials. The oysters and fried chicken are especially recommended. The best table…
Top Choice Gastropub in Phoenicia & Mt Tremper

Tavern 214

Tavern 214 has a great menu of classic American comfort food inspired entrees, but it's the small plates where this lodge style tavern shines. Duck breast quesadillas, deconstructed poke bowls, and sausage and peppe…
Top Choice American in Phoenicia & Mt Tremper

Phoenicia Diner

New York hipsters and local families rub shoulders at this elevated roadside diner. The appealing menu offers all-day breakfast, skillets, sandwiches and burgers – all farm-fresh and fabulous.
Top Choice Vegan in Woodstock

Garden Cafe

All the ingredients used at this relaxed, charming cafe are organic. The food served is appealing, tasty and fresh, and includes salads, sandwiches, rice bowls and veggie lasagna. It also serves freshly made juices,…
American in Phoenicia & Mt Tremper


One of the finest restaurant in the Catskills, this renovated farmhouse has been promoting local farm-to-table dining for more than a decade. The menu changes daily, although the braised beef short ribs are a perman…
American in Tannersville


A circular bar and wraparound windows with mountain views take center stage at the appealing restaurant and bar of Scribner's Catskill Lodge. The food features local produce and a tempting mix of dishes, several of …
American in Tannersville

Jessie's Harvest House

Located just outside of Tannersville's main strip, the dining room at Jessie's Harvest House is spread out over the ground floor of a charming home. There's a great selection of mains and some small plates that offe…
Cafe in Tannersville

Twin Peaks Coffee & Donuts

Twin Peaks is a large coffee shop with a friendly owner and a small menu of well-made sandwiches and basic breakfast items. Its claim-to-fame are the made-to-order donuts. Classic flavors like chocolate glaze are on…
Pizza in Narrowsburg


With toppings such as black garlic and kimchee, this is far from your average pizza joint. Also on the menu are organic hot dogs, upscale dips and cocktails. Occupying a former laundry (hence the name), it has a gre…
Cafe in Callicoon

Cafe Adella Dori

There's an East European Jewish influence to some of the bakes and dishes served at this arty cafe, run by Eva, the daughter of Dori and granddaughter of Adella – hence the business name. One of Callicoon's cutest d…