| Lonely Planet™ · Thorn Tree Forum · 2020 | ![]() |
Marseille current safety and crimeCountry forums / Western Europe / France | ||
I’m an English guy who’s been living in Marseille since July 2014 and am offering an update on the crime and safety situation from a local perspective. | ||
This post has been removed because it may not have met our community guidelines. | 1 | |
thanks a lot tommo for all the great information on marseille. #1 im totally for freedom of religion and opinions. but enforcing the sharia law ? i hope you are not serious. | 2 | |
This post has been removed because it may not have met our community guidelines. | 3 | |
Well, I am one of those people who spent some time in central Marseille (including the sleazy areas) and felt completely safe, even when taking pictures of "local colour." I will admit that I had no reason or inclination to go to the northern arrondissements, so I cannot comment about them. Tommo68, the vast majority of the dangers that you describe also exist in Paris, which is a city that generally has a good reputation in spite of these problems. I live in one of the poorest parts of Paris, full of refugees and petty crime, not to mention drug dealers. Frankly, I spend little or no time out on the streets between 2 and 6am which is when most of the unsavoury things happen (probably true for just about any city), so I find your report both sincere and unnecessarily alarmist. Do you think you are really helping by scaring people about Marseille? I'll admit that my last trip there dates from 2 years ago, but my experience was so positive that I am a bit dismayed by some of your observations. Here is the report that I made: Marseille kaleidoscope | 4 | |
Sure, the dangers I describe exist in just about any city, but to a greater degree in parts of Marseille than others. I don't think it's alarmist to describe the very real dangers that at the time of writing are present largely in the 1st, 2nd and 3rd arrondissements. Other Marseille residents will back up what I say. If people reading my post are 'scared' then that is their response to my writing, I'm simply conveying my experience of the city, which is that it it's somewhere you need to keep a hold on your belongings and be aware of what's going on around you to a greater extent than is perhaps the case in other cities. I understand now there are parts of Marseille that are simply no go areas. I used to dismiss this, having lived here now I understand people are serious when they say for example they don't go into most of the third arrondissement and if they drive through Port d'Aix they keep the doors and windows of the car locked and at night don't stop for red lights. 'Do you think you are really helping by scaring people about Marseille?' ... I'm just saying, Just saying what I've seen and experienced. | 5 | |
Last known number of inhabitants in 2012 in Marseille: 850.726 - today probably some hundreds more including you. Do you think they all have the same experience as you wrote down here? | 6 | |
My friends from Marseille also discourage me from visiting. I went anyway. I am loath to say this but my recollection is of a dirty, large city that smelt of urine. I am aware the old port is being redesigned. Relative to Nice or Paris, Marseille is not for me. | 7 | |
'a dirty, large city that smelt of urine' is a bit of an exaggeration. The Panier district and other areas near the old port have become very gentrified in recent years. Around Rue Paradis, Rue du Rome the city is very chic. Marseille is a lot less pretentious, a lot grittier than Paris. Nice is full of wealthy and nouveaux riche. Personally, I prefer Marseille, a much more interesting and dynamic city with thousands of years of history than Nice which is nothing more than a somewhat upscale beach resort. | 8 | |
I most definitely prefer Marseille to Nice. | 9 | |
I've never been to Marseille. And tmrw I think I will have to walk from Place Castellane to the area around Blancarde metro station at about 0100 - carrying a laptop! Is this a dodgy part of town? Should I ensure I take a taxi instead? Thanks | 10 | |
People (including miscreants) will still be busy celebrating the victory of France over Germany. ;-) It is still central Marseille and Boulevard Baille is a main thoroughfare. It wouldn't bother me, but of course I would stay on my guard at all times, the same as in Paris at 1 a.m. I will refresh my personal knowledge of Marseille next week when I spend a few days there. | 11 | |
OK thanks, I was mainly checking this is not a "dangerous" part of the city | 12 | |
tommo68, thank you so much for this detailed and honest post. No, not every city is equally dangerous. Yes, there are some cities that are simply worse than others. I don't know why people represent otherwise. As a petite, solo female traveler with children to return home to, I always seek advice about the safety of my potential travel destinations. Advice from people who actually live there, and that includes feedback from other people who actually live there, is absolutely invaluable. Based on such advice, I safely visited Rio de Janeiro by myself (a few years ago) but decided to pass, for example, on Naples (this year). I am still up in the air on Marseilles, but this has given me a lot to work with. Thank you! | 13 | |
Rio is 10 times more dangerous than Marseille or Naples. | 14 | |
Depends on where you go. I researched neighborhoods very carefully and had no problems and never felt unsafe. And again, this was during a period of relative 'detante' in Rio re: police and gang relations. | 15 | |
Your research told you Naples was dangerous? Why does Rick Steves like it so much? | 16 | |
No idea; I don't follow Rick Steves. Naples residents told me it was dangerous, and described specific crimes they had witnessed, so I took their word for it. | 17 | |
And what crimes were those?
But you're surely aware of him and what he does: offers N. American first-timers "Europe with training wheels." btw, I have an American friend who, with her sister and her sister's friend (all women in their late 40's or older), used Naples as a base for 2 weeks last summer. No issues. I'm pretty sure that's the norm. There are plenty of reasons not to visit Naples, if that's what you're looking for. Fear of crime isn't one of them. | 18 | |
You are certainly entitled to your opinion and your anecdotal examples. I am not interested in continuing this conversation because your intent seems to be just to troll. Perhaps someone else will take you up on that offer. Best wishes. | 19 | |
Ditto! | 20 | |
A sometimes useful guide: In recent years muggings and pickpockets have dramatically decreased in the city center, however, avoid carrying valuables and watch your surroundings. Most of the northern neighborhoods (quartiers nord), except L'Estaque and Château-Gombert, might be risky and should be avoided by tourists and there is no logical reason for going there. | 21 | |
Hello there, | 22 | |
Hi sfgirl42 and tommo68, thanks for your great posts. sfgirl42, I will check out all those links and tommo68, thank you for the feedback from the German woman who recently stayed with you. It's funny -- I actually like a certain rebelliousness to a city. I live an hour outside of New York, and I remember loving Times Square back when it was gritty, colorful and edgy. Now it has been Disney-fied and is clean, safe and entirely lacking in character. So I appreciate what you mean. I am constantly trying to balance safety against other desirable qualities like diversity and uniqueness. On this particular trip to France, I will be with a wonderful older friend who is not in great physical condition and not terribly street-smart. My concern is more over her; that she, specifically, might make an easy target. I will read both of your posts in more detail and continue to gather information. I think we can probably figure out a way to visit Marseilles without having a problem. Merci again! | 23 | |
Thanks to John Steed and others who have the courage to tell it like it is. I love Marseilles but forewarned is forearmed. Nothing he's reported deters me in the least of revisiting one of my favorite French cities, especially now that I know more about how to be particularly aware. | 24 | |
"Tell it like it is" ? I don't think that the experience of one person applies to everyone. I would think that everyone knows already that caution should be applied in any big city. I live in "safe" Paris and I am fully aware of possible dangers. | 25 | |
Funny, the only place I've EVER been accosted in Europe, in over 45 years of travel, is Paris, in the subway by a young Arab couple two Mays ago. Unfortunately for them, I fought them both off w/o any difficulty and left them both yelling at and blaming each other for having botched the attempted theft, to my fellow passengers' great delight. Yes, "tell it like it is" is always preferable to "saying the thing which is not." | 26 | |
Appearing to be rich is a magnet for thieves anywhere in the world, but it's advisable to realise that wealth is relative. | 27 | |
I have been to Marseille five times in the last three years and love it. Before I stayed there I'd been led to believe it was the crime capital of France, but I'm now convinced that is a rumour put about by the Parisian tourist board! Like any big(gish) city, it has its rough areas, but I can't say I felt any more vulnerable in them than I have done in the equivalent areas of any major city. I went to Bougainville during the day, mainly to check it out. It was very run down with the usual attributes of such an area, but I didn't find it particularly threatening. I wouldn't recommend visiting the area simply because it's pretty redundant of saving graces, rather than any obvious dangers. I have stayed mainly around Vieux Port and Le Panier which have become very gentrified and feel very comfortable. I've noticed nothing particularly alarming happening in the streets around there, but would acknowledge that I rarely stay out much after 10pm, so perhaps I've witnessed it at its best! Any time I've stayed out later than that, it has always been around Place de Lenche, which has always seemed most genteel. The local boulangerie both open way past 10pm and I can't imagine they'd do that if the area was dangerous. I did have my phone pickpocketed at Vieux Port metro, but that was my own stupid fault and could have happened in any major city centre. I wouldn't presume to correct people who've actually lived in Marseille for any length of time, but far from being crime ridden, I've been surprised how relatively crime free the beaches around Prado are. People routinely leave their possessions unattended, whilst they swim or go for a walk, but I've not heard a single story about anybody having anything stolen. The staff in the local Casino supermarket and local resident Laurent, who visits Plage David daily, from April to September, confirmed there was little incidence of reported crime in the area. Even the flea market which stretches for about a kilometre at weekends, is relatively scam free. Marseille is a strange city though, for example whilst it doesn't seem to actively encourage tourists to visit, it treats the ones who find their way there better than any other city I've visited. In the final analysis, it is probably the most 'user-friendly' city I've ever visited, as can be exemplified by its 7 day travel pass, which entitles the traveller to unlimited journeys on metro, tram, bus and certain rail routes, as well as amazing bonuses such as the coach to Cassis and the boat to Estaque. It costs just €13.00, which is less than it costs for an all zone travel card in London, valid for just a single day. In all five previous visits to Marseille, the only 'trouble' I've witnessed, was a rather violent domestic which spilled onto the street in La Blancarde, again, not really a tourist destination. Despite the warnings of others, I find Marseille to be far less threatening than London, Paris, Rome or any other big cities I know. Yes it is down at heel in many areas, but in an attractively Bohemian way. It has swanky areas, but they don't feel exclusive, in the literal sense. Overall, Marseille has a vibrancy missing in the corporate theme parks that London, Paris and Milan have become and I'll be back there in September. | 28 | |
In terms of "crime capital of France," I am pretty sure that it is the murder capital of France but only if you are a drug dealer in the northern fringe of the city where even I have never been. Down along the seafront and the Vieux Port, I have never seen the slightest problem. | 29 | |
Excellent post, flip_city. My thoughts exactly about Marseille, where I spent a very enjoyable week in Sta. Giniez last month. One of the highlights: a great meal at Lido Saigon, a French-Vietnamese restaurant just west of Plage David. As the French couple next to us remarked, "This IS the best Vietnamese restaurant in Marseilles!" Definitely going back for more! | 30 | |
Frankly, sounds like my kind of town. I'm not sure that Chicago is the Marseille of the US. | 31 | |
Last time I was in Marseille I had quite a good (and cheap) meal at Le Moyen Orient, a Syrian restaurant just off the Vieux Port. Not a tourist in sight because they are all 50 metres away on the waterfront. | 32 | |
This topic has been automatically locked due to inactivity. Email community@lonelyplanet.com if you would like to add to this topic and we'll unlock it for you. | 33 | |