3.5 weeks in China in August - first north or first south?

I'd already asked about beaches in China and wanted to thank all who commented. Based on some suggestions we've now got a kind of plan, skipping the beaches, but my question is whether we should go first north bound or south bound or does it matter, re. weather or any other considerations?

We arrive in Xi'an on 7 Aug and leave from Xi'an on 31 Aug
the north bound trip would be:
Xi'an, including trips to Huashan, Longmen and Shaolin (or staying one night in Luoyang)
Ping Yao
Beijing
Taishan
Huangshan
Guilin
Zhangjiajie

the south bound trip would be the same places, but going first to Zhangjiajie, after the first days in Xi'an, etc.

We plan to take only trains, but I realise that the Xi'an - Zhangjiajie is quite a long one, with not the best arrival times. So may have to fly that leg.

Thanks for your comments!
Paivi

And, a bit off of my topic ;-) but would you wear trainers when climbing the mountains or would you rather have light but proper hiking shoes?

And, a bit off of my topic ;-) but would you wear trainers when climbing the mountains or would you rather have light but proper hiking shoes?

The mountains will be nearly entirely concrete stairs. There are a few overlooks with wooden planks and some parts of the train that are flat exposed rock. Plan your footwear accordingly. I would wear tennis shoes(trainers)

I'd already asked about beaches in China and wanted to thank all who commented. Based on some suggestions we've now got a kind of plan, skipping the beaches, but my question is whether we should go first north bound or south bound or does it matter, re. weather or any other considerations?

I would head NE first, from Xi'an towards Pingyao then Beijing. Follow the heart of Northern China until you reach the pinnacle of imperial power. Then head south stopping off at Taishan and maybe Qufu before getting to Huangshan, which is surrounded by Huizhou architecture taht is completely different form what you will see in Shaanxi, Shanxi, Beijnig, and Shandong.

Then Guilin which is yet more different
Then Zhangjiajie
Then come back and decide if you want to bother hiking Huashan or going to Shaolin. Even if you do the itinerary in reverse, I would save these 2 for last.

I think you might be overloading on chinese mountains, including one is certianly worthwhile. 2 is stretching it, but Taishan and Huangshan are different and both revered. Three and I think you might get sick of the concrete stairs and the throngs of tourists slowly marching up the hill past endless stands selling processed hotdogs and sweet green tea. So saving Huashan for last means you can possible skip it if your interests change

Saving Shaolin is the same idea. It will give you time to appreciate what mass market Chinese tourism is, and how it turns historic sites into Disneyland like versions of themselves. Shaolin was a very small temple complex that was virtually abandoned just a few decades ago. Since then rampant tourist development has increased the size of the temple by 20 fold and set up and entire industry of souvenier hawkers and small Kungfu academies, most just in the last 5-10 years.

We plan to take only trains, but I realise that the Xi'an - Zhangjiajie is quite a long one, with not the best arrival times. So may have to fly that leg.

Flying can really save you some time and aggravation. If you want to be flexible, trains might sell out.

That was kind of what I was thinking - I don't have proper hiking shoes at the moment and breaking in new ones will take time, so will probably rely on trainers. Just need test them on slippery surfaces in case of rain.

Thanks for your thoughts. Going to Beijing at the first half of the trip might be sensible, when you still have a lot of energy and then chill down in the nature areas.

This topic has been automatically locked due to inactivity. Email community@lonelyplanet.com if you would like to add to this topic and we'll unlock it for you.