Enter custom title (optional)
This topic is locked
Last reply was
1.5k
10

"After considering a few names beginning with H" is an adverb clause containing the PARTICIPIAL phrase "considering a few names beginning with H." "Beginning with H" is a participial phrase modifying "names."

Report
11

#10 -- a participle functions as an adjective. A gerund functions as a noun. (Do you agree so far?)

What noun or pronoun is "considering" modifying in that sentence?

What noun or pronoun is the object of the preposition "after"?

Report
12

#11 - In this sentence, "after" is not used as a preposition; it is used as a conjunction.

Report
13

ergo, neither are gerunds; both are participles

Report
14

Then what's the finite verb in the clause introduced by the conjunction "after"? What tense is it? What's it's subject?

E.g. in the clause "After they considered a few names beginning with H, . . . ", "After" is a conjunction; "considered" is the finite verb; it's in the past tense; and "they" is its subject.

Report
15

no, i take it back. "after" is a preposition in that sentence, and "considering" is a gerund. vinny is right

Report
16

I'm with Vinny, too. "After (preposition) + considering (gerund) a few names (rest of noun phrase) beginning (participle) with H, ..."

Participles function as adjectives and verbs, never nouns.

Report
17

If you want to get precise, "a few names" is the object of the gerund.

Report
18

For what it's worth...

"After considering a few names beginning with H"
("After (we) considered a few names (that) begin with H")

I would consider this to be two reduced participle clauses, the first being adverbial and the second adjectival. "After" is a preposition in this case (although it can be a conjunction, but not here) as there are no complete (i.e. finite) clauses following it.

Both "considering" and "beginning" are present participles, then. Participles may not be nouns per se, but they can be the object of a preposition in participle clauses (like "on arriving, we went straight to the bar").

Report
19

#18 -- This is getting tiresome. II "on arriving", "arriving" is a gerund. How do I know that? Because it's the object of a preposition. In "The train arriving on track 9 is the Panama Limited", "arriving" is a participle, modifying a noun.

You're right that the prepositional phrase "After considering" functions adverbially.

Report
Pro tip
Lonely Planet
trusted partner