Enter custom title (optional)
This topic is locked
Last reply was
2.0k

Watched 'My Kitchen Rules' the other night, yes, i know i'm a bit of a tragic when it come's to cooking shows on the teev, watching Sammi & Bella doing stock, they firsty browned all the ingrediants over a high heat, and then added hot water and seasoning. When making my stock i just toss all of my ingrediants into hot seasoned water, and the only reason i would think that browning them off may add flavour, does any body know for sure why they did do this?

Report
1

It gives better flavour and better colour.

Report
2

Iv'e never seen done before, is there any thing to do with their restriced time they have to add flavour?

Report
3

No. It's for the same flavors that come from browning in any cooking process.

Report
4

Maybe some cultures brown vegetables before making a broth or stock, but when I think back to my grandmother's chicken soup, the process was to clean and chop some carrots and celery, put them in a big pot with a halved onion, place a whole chicken in the pot, add water and boil. That stock was pretty tasty.

Report
5

I wouldn't say browning gives better flavors. It gives different flavors, which many people prefer.

Irish stew is traditionally made with lamb that isn't browned. I should say "was traditionally made". I don't know if anyone makes it that way any more.

Report
6

I agree with Vinny. There two kinds of chicken stock, for instance--white stock and brown stock. I make both. For white stock, nothing is browned. It's pale and has a milder, more delicate flavor and it's also, well, white. I use it where I want a more subtle flavor, or if the finished dish needs to be pale, such as some white sauces.

I use brown chicken sauce more often because it has a richer flavor. I brown the meat and onions for sure. If I am adding that bag of veggie trimmings from the freezer, I don't brown them, but if I'm adding fresh, raw veggies, I usually do. Except garlic--it can become bitter when browned--and herbs which don't brown well.

For beef stock, I always brown the meat. I want this as rich as possible.

I'd never brown ingredients for fish stock, which I rarely make.


Nutrax
The plural of anecdote is not data.
Report
7

Just for the record, the final was on last night, and the sisters Sammi & Balla did win, jeez these girls can indeed cook!

Report
8

That process is called the Maillard reaction
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maillard_reaction
The heat causes a chemical reaction to occur which changes both taste and color.

Report
9

There are other things that can be going on in browning, castaway_girl, notably caramelization of the sugars e.g. in the onions, carrots, and parsnips. (Or leek, carrot, and parsnip trimmings if you make stock the way I do.)

Report
Pro tip
Lonely Planet
trusted partner