I don't like the chocolate ones very much.
My preferences are no anise (I didn't know that version even existed), rolled in to balls before being baked, and shaken in a bag with powdered sugar when they're warm from the oven.
I'm rather pfond of pfeffernuesse and like them nutless but with anise. I also like a thin, crisp sugar glaze, pfurther dusted with powdered sugar.
They are difficult to make "just right". Archway Cookies used to make a very good version, if you could pfind them in your pfavorite store. But then Archway went ka-pflooie.
Actually, the cookies I've had that were called pfeffernuesse were crescent shaped. The marble sized rounds are what my mother calls angel anns. I do like the round ones better.
It's hardly a scientific survey, but when I looked at Pfefferrnusse on google images, I got an interesting split. When it was just "Pfeffernusse," a lot of the pictures showed cookies covered with powdered sugar (confectioners' sugar, icing sugar). Some round, some flat-bottomed.
If I restricted the hits to German web sites, most of the cookies were flat-bottomed & glazed or iced.
