I highly recommend you to stay in the 11th. Ile de la Jatte is out of town, and I mean out of Neuilly !! which is quite far from Paris and any convenient transportation (no metro in that area, only buses at about 10 minutes walking distance from the hotel).
And don't be sorry, your question was pretty clear.
10

jedy
11

kaleidoscopecupcakes
Thanks Jedy, I think that staying central seems to be the best option. I am currently looking at the 5th and 11th, and perhaps montmartre? Everywhere seems to be pretty booked up though so starting to wonder if my trip to Paris will happen at all! Thank you so much to everyone who's been so helpful.
Pro tip