Thanks everyone! I appreciate your answers.
I am still trying to find out if, as a Canadian citizen, I need a return plane ticket just to enter the country. My government website says "yes... but don't take our word on it", the airlines say to contact the Iceland consulate, the consulate was sick with the flu and referred me to the Iceland embassy... and they were closed for the weekend! I think I probably do, which is hard because I would like to carry on to Europe if I have enough money left, or come home and get a job if I haven't. Either way, I'll have my tickets booked this week. :)