Enter custom title (optional)
This topic is locked
Last reply was
3.4k

Name some:

Songs or bands (or for classical folks, pieces or composers) that everyone and his kid brother seem to love, but that you, personally, cannot stand. Alternatively, the opposite: songs or bands that you adore but that critics and/or public just never warmed to.

Give at least three or four words of explanation, so that this can turn into an actual discussion rather than just a list of various opinions.

I'll start: I really HATE John Lennon's "Imagine." The message* is not only mush-headed but muddled. The instrumentation and structure is simplistic and repetitive. In short, it's an awful song. You can't escape from the damn thing either, since it still gets played far too much. And yet, when you tell people you don't like the song, they stare at you like you just said you eat puppies.

--M.

*Y'know, I don't really mind the message itself -- or I wouldn't if it actually had a single clear message. It's just that it's incoherent. Peace and love and all that are nice--but communism, anarchy, and atheism thrown in for good measure, and all together in one single midden heap?

Edited by: mrpenney to add footnote

Report
1

I've talked about this here and on other forums over the years - that Imagine is one of the sappiest pieces of bubblegum I've ever heard - although I do like the way A Perfect Circle covered it - dark and broody, made a world of difference in the song - not a big solo Lennon, Lennon/Ono fan to begin with

have to think about the rest of the question

Report
2

I don't like Elvis or Jimi Hendrix.

Report
3

I'll be shot for saying this but as much as Hendrix is revered for technique, and rightly so, I don't find the music itself all that relevant today - although back then I'd have to say I was among the masses on Hendrix

Elvis is another story - I don't see him as "The King" but I still like a good Elvis tune

I'm still thinking - I know there are some but right now I'm drawing a blank until people mention them

Report
4

If JR were here I'd have to give honorable mention to Mr. Monotone and Mr. Whine and Cheese just to do it

Report
5

Bob Dylan. I don't understand where all the love comes from. "But...but...he's the GREATEST POET OF OUR GENERA TION...yadda yadda..." I can hardly understand him, and his nasally whine is more than I can handle for more than 1 or 2 songs.

Celine Dion: She doesn't really sing, so much as yell out lyrics with far more passion and volume than the lyrics require. Her voice isn't bad at all, it's what she does with it.

Jonas Brothers: Why are they even mildly famous?

Amy Winehouse: Why is she even mildly famous, other than for being a walking trainwreck?

Report
6

Sweet Home Alabama. God that song is just about the crappiest most repetitive piece of crap ever written. Its my veto song for my covers band.

Unluckily, that means I have to place eagles songs. Who are just about the most boring band I've ever heard. I just don't get it.

The worst thing about not liking these bands is that people then try and convince you that you are indeed wrong. For like 30 minutes.

I don't have guilty pleasures I like some will young, daniel bedingfield and make no excuses.

but I hate it when people underrmine a band I love because they went on to release shoddy material. Such as the offspring, the shamen, manic street preachers, ocean colour scene.

In the words of scrubious pip...' thou shall not put bands and recording artists on a rediculous pedistool, no matter how good they are or were....the beatles, just a band, the beach boys, just a band, the pistols, just a band.....the next big thing, just a band'

Report
7

Sweet Home Alabama. God that song is just about the crappiest most repetitive piece of crap ever written. Its my veto song for my covers band.

The worst thing, from my point of view, is that everything of any value in that song was ripped off of Neil Young. Intentionally, of course, to make a point. But that makes it worse, if anything.

Neil Young may have been unfair to the state of Alabama, but his is much the better song.

--M.

Report
8

REM. Whining, jangly, middle of the road, self-indulgent twaddle. And I hate the guy's voice.

Report
9

Hehe... I like this thread. Right, then: Phil Collins. I love A Trick of the Tail (Genesis, 1976), however once he went solo he became sappy, cheesy and a serious candidate for the world's #1 über schmaltzmeister. Then again, commercial pop in the 80s were generally a bloody nuisance anyway. Jon English, Chris de Burgh, Elton John, Bryan Adams, Duran Duran, Modern Talking... the list goes on. Patrick Bateman's views in B E Ellis' American Psycho on Genesis, Whitney Houston and Huey Lewis and The News make for some good laughs.

Report
Pro tip
Lonely Planet
trusted partner