Enter custom title (optional)
This topic is locked
Last reply was
7.2k

Hi there
We just got back from Sumatra - and I feel like I have to write something about our trip here because I benefitted a lot from all the posts about Sumatra in this forum (eg. Pamela and others).

The problem is: I really don't know where to start :-).

First the facts: We stayed 4 weeks on the whole and travelled the "usual road" from north (Medan) to the west (Padang). We spent about a week in Bukit Lawang, a few days on Lake Toba, a week in Bukittinggi area (and Lake Maninjau), 3 days in the Kerinci Seblat National Park (Jambi), 2 days at Bungus Beach near Padang and the last day in Padang.

The trip was one the best trips we have ever made. We've absolutely fallen in love with Sumatra - so: if you have the chance to go there: DO IT!

All the informations below are personal impressions, of course.

  1. Bukit Lawang
    If I could, I'd go back to Bukit Lawang straight away - we loved that place! We stayed at the "famous" Jungle Inn, in our opinion the best place to stay (because of its character and location). We arranged a pickup from Medan airport which was very convenient. In Bukit Lawang, we did a 5 days Jungle Trek. Most of the people opt for a shorter trek, one or two days - so other tourists there were quite surprised we did 5 days (in rainy season). We think it was the best choice we've made. Yes, it was muddy and sometimes exhausting, yes, there were leeches. But this is the only way to really see something of the Jungle! If you do the one or two days trek you don't really get into the jungle. If you need more information about our trek please ask, I can't really write everything down here :-) But still - if you're not so much into the rainforest as we are - it still worth going to Bukit Lawang - just for the views out of the Jungle Inn!!

  2. We chose the longer road to Lake Toba over Brastagi and the Sipisopiso Waterfull. The views were great! Arrived in Prapat quite late and there was no ferry anymore (the last one goes at about 7). We stayed in the rather overpriced and a little bit shabby Charlie Guesthouse. In the morning we took the ferry to TukTuk. We stayed at "Romlan's", a place owned by German woman and her Indonesian husband. We liked the place. In our opinion, it was better than the other ones like Bagus, Tabo, Carolina (too big). The rooms were very clean and comfy and had great views on the lake. The place was good for swimming and the water seemed to be very clean. We did some trips on Samosir (to the usual places) by motorbike (more info? just ask...). No matter what people tell you about the road going south around Samosir: They're rebuilding it and most of the road is new by now. For the views: Head south, up the hill - absolutely fantastic!!

  3. We took the bus from Prapat to Bukittinggi. It's a long way, it took us 18 hours. It's a night bus, opt for the Super Executive and buy the tickets at your hotel and not at the office in Prapat (they're much more expensive there!). The bus ride was quite an adventure - a big part of the road through the mountains is unsealed - we even had to get off the bus and walk up the hill at 3o'clock in the morning... The whole journey is nothing for those with weak stomachs... ;-) We still liked the ride, it was quite an adventure and something you remember for a long time.
    Bukittinggi is a nice place, we stayed at the Orchid. Ronny, the guide of the Orchid and his friends are great fun and we had a very good time together! We did a two day trek to Lake Maninjau from Bukittinggi - staying overnight at Anas Homestay (a very basic place at the slope down to lake Manijau). We had an upstairs room with no walls overlooking the lake. I've never had a room with such a view out of the bed! At Maninjau we stayed at Lily's, a nice place in Bayur. We went around the lake by motorbike. We couldn't swim because of that "dead fish problem" (more infos? -> ask), the water was murky and smelly. On the whole we were a little bit disappointed of Lake Maninjau: We had read so many good things about it and expected something great. We thought Maninjau is a good place if you have no time to go to lake Toba, but in no way comparable to it. Toba is much more beautiful.

  4. From Bukittinggi we took a 7 hours Bus ride to the Kerinci Seblat National Park. There is a direct bus going there (which means you don't have to go through Padang), the road is good and the views out uf the bus are absolutely stunning. You drive trough tropical rice paddy fields up the mountains and then trough tea plantations, passing mountain lakes... We stayed at Subandi's Homestay in Kersik Tua, ask for it, everyone knows. We did a two day trek up Mount Tujuh, camping at the crater lake. We had Endatno as guide, he absolutely fantastic. He know so much about the rainforest, he knew the birds of the sounds they were making. Compared to our guides at Bukit Lawang he knew a lot more about nature, wildlife and so on. His English was very good, too. So if you've got serious interest in flora and fauna you'd probably spend more days at Kerinci and less in Bukit Lawang.

  5. From Kerinci we went down to the coast, to Bungus Beach close to Padang. We stayed at Carlos' the place almost every tourist stays. The beach was average - but the snorkling trip to the islands close to Bungus (south) was fantastic. If we had had more time we would have made an overnight trip with camping on the islands...

  6. We finally arrived in Padang and stayed there for the last days, just eating wonderful Padang food and doing some shopping.

Some general words about travelling in Sumatra:
Lonely Planet Guidebook
I know this is the Lonely Planet forum - but I really have to say it here: Forget about the Lonely Planet (Indonsia, Sumatra part). Almost every information there is wrong and gives you a very wrong impression. The so called "touts", for example, that are so often mentioned in the Lonely Planet, they don't exist on Sumatra!! We haven't met any tourist tout on the whole trip.
Tourists
There are NO tourists on Sumatra, no matter what the Lonely Planet says. You'll be the only tourist on the plane to Medan and you'll be greeted by everyone. People that work in tourism kept on telling us about the "golden age" (1991-1995) when there were quite a few tourists going to Sumatra, but now, after the Bali bombs, the Tsunami and the earthquakes there is almost no tourists left - which is - for the individual traveller - great.
Prices
Sumatra is very very cheap, cheaper than Thailand, p.e. The usual room costs about 3 to 5 dollars, the usual Padang food 1 dollar.
People
The people are so very friendly and cordial, we've really fallen in love with them.
Why Sumatra?
Because there are no tourists, people are friendly and reserved (there are no aggressive touts or something like that), you can have everything on Sumatra: Climb volcanoes, see Orang Utans, go jungle trekking in virgin rainforest, snorkel at tropical beaches, swim im crater lakes, eat delicious food...

I'm sure I have forgotten many things - please ask.

Yours,
Marionna

Report
1

Nice post - though I feel I might add that most of the positives you mention about Sumatra also apply for pretty much everywhere else in Indonesia (except for parts of Bali and Yogya, perhaps), in some cases being even more so.
Basically, the further one goes from Bali and Java, the rarer the tourists and the friendlier the locals, though prices can also be higher.

You've clearly also made the right decision by choosing to spend the full month in one region of the country, though hopefully this experience will also tempt you to return and see more of Indonesia!


My info & thoughts:
on East-Indonesia.info: Indonesia, Maluku, West Papua, Raja Ampat & Indonesian Visas
on Thorn Tree: Seeing Orangutans, Kalimantan, Kiribati & Tuvalu
Report
2

@Laszlo: You are right - this was our first visit to Indonesia - but not the last, for sure! :-)

Report
3

great post what would you do if you only had approx 2 weeks our teenagers like to travel but are not great on long windey bus trips Lake toba sounds great and any nice beaches and mayby a short taste of jungle

Report
4

skidrowe -- I notice you have similar posts about sumatra recently in other forums so this may answer them all. Yes, two weeks in North Sumatra is a good idea. You can fly there (to Medan) by Air Asia from KL at least. You can also take a ferry from Pedang (only a few times a week now) see Langkawi Ferries too.

See Bukit Lawang and Danau Toba -- OP did it very well. Her(?) suggestons are about as good as any. If you have time left over in two weeks add Tangkahan (has lts of walks, swimming in the river, hot springs and elephant rides, not in current LP) rather than go south for such a short time.

Paul

Report
5

Thanks for making this post Marionna. I'm going to be heading to Sumatra in just over a week and your writing has given me some great info for my own trip.

I've been reading the Lonely Planet guide and I've found it to be a very negative read. Now I've had a lot of experience with Lonely Planet books and I understand that its writings are just opinions and one person might love what another hates, this particular edition though has to have been the most negative I've come across and it's making my hunt for facts quite difficult.

One thing I'm struggling to work out at the moment is how I get from Singapore to Sumatra. Suggested ferry ports to arrive to. The guide gives some examples but ends them in a negative way that tries to dissuade someone from taking such a route. Either it being expensive, or the port town not being a good destination or the general hassle of a ferry compared to flight.

Can anyone post of their experiences of travelling from Singapore to Sumatra (any destination).

Report
6

The easiest and cheapest way from Singapore to Sumatra is usaually a Tiger Airways flight to Padang for as little as 25 USD OW.
It is a long and boring journey by boat and bus via the islands and mainland of Riau.


My info & thoughts:
on East-Indonesia.info: Indonesia, Maluku, West Papua, Raja Ampat & Indonesian Visas
on Thorn Tree: Seeing Orangutans, Kalimantan, Kiribati & Tuvalu
Report
7

Have also flown from SIngapore to Padang. It's very cheap and just a one hour flight.

Thanks for the great report marionna.

Report
8

I mentioned KL as skidmore mentioned Air Asia in one of his posts in another branch, near this one, and KL is its base. If we knew where skidmore is hitting asia; or even where he comes from we vould be more precise.

I for one like boat travel and am happy to go Sumatra taking a ferry SGP to Batam and from there Pekanbaru (as long as I do not have to get out at Tanjong Buton). I have recently travelled from Jambi to Batam by ferry. For a first timer to Indonesia I believe North Sumatra is better than West. marionna's first two points were good

There is a lot of information on Sumatra in TT; searching will turn up a lot more.

Paul

Report
9

@skidrowe: If I had two weeks I'd choose either North Sumatra (Bukit Lawang and Lake Toba) or West Sumatra (Bukittinggi Area). If you're into the beach West Sumatra is better. You could, p.e., spend 5 days in Bukittinggi town and do day trips (p.e. see the Rafflesia) from there, then do the jungle trek to Maninjau (a little bit of jungle and some lonely leeches :-)) and spend 3 days at Maninjau, just swimming and relaxing. Back to Bukittinggi and down to Bungus Beach for the last couple of days.
Marionna

Report
Pro tip
Lonely Planet
trusted partner