Lonely Planet Writer

Toronto's plan to have different rules for traditional taxis and Uber cars meets with resistance

Toronto is considering the introduction of separate regulations for taxi and Uber drivers.

Uber services
Uber services and Taxis could have a different set of rules under new proposals put forward by Toronto Image by Joakim Formo / CC BY 2.0

The Toronto Star understands that the intention is to accommodate Uber and other ride-sharing services while also freeing up regulations which apply to the traditional taxi industry. Some of the deregulation may be phased in slowly to protect cabbies, many of whom do not actually own the vehicles they drive.

Taxi drivers are required to have their vehicles inspected twice yearly while Uber drivers need to have theirs inspected only on an annual basis
Taxi drivers are required to have their vehicles inspected twice yearly while Uber drivers need to have theirs inspected only on an annual basis Image by Alessandro Prada / CC BY-SA 2.0

However taxi industry chiefs rejected the proposals before they were released. They want a single set of rules for both types of transport hire. The executive director of the Toronto Taxi Alliance, Rita Smith, said they demand the same set of rules for all. She expressed disappointment that Uber couldn’t compete on a level playing field by seeking a special set of rules. Among the changes mooted is a requirement for Uber vehicles to be inspected every year. This differs from cabs which need twice yearly inspections. However, both cabbies and Uber drivers would face similar criminal record checks.

The new proposals would allow taxi companies, currently restricted to regulated fares, to discount their rates on app- or phone-dispatched rides. This would allow them to become competitive with Uber. Mayor John Tory dismissed the notion of one set of regulations for all, claiming that they are two different businesses. He said it is the city’s intention to have fair rules for the two sides of the industry.