Mar 7, 2011 3:45:39 AM
Too soon? 5 questions to ask when disaster strikes your travel plans.
Note: Javascript is disabled in your browser.
To see the gallery in all its glory, you'll need to enable Javascript.
Has a disaster ever forced you to rethink travel plans drastically?
When calamity strikes, it’s tough to think of yourself. Earthquakes, hurricanes and civil wars cause unimaginable devastation and tragedy for the people who are directly affected. In comparison, your itinerary feels insignificant.
But as the dust settles, you’ll need to make a plan. Should you cancel your well-earned holiday? Should you look for an alternative destination? Or should you just suck it up and plough on through?
How you respond should hinge on the answers to the following questions:
1. Is it safe?
Your safety is paramount. This is not the time to rely on hearsay. While Twitter is a great source for breaking news, it’s not the perfect place to assess an on-the-ground situation (unless you have enormous faith in your followers).
Your first port of call is your government’s foreign-travel website. Official sites are updated frequently, and their warnings often carry insurance implications. It’s important to understand that these sites will naturally err on the side of conservatism – it’s their responsibility to keep you safe, not to ensure that you have an adventure!
Here are some well-maintained sites: travel.state.gov (USA), Foreign Office (UK), Smartraveller (Australia), Safe Travel (New Zealand), Foreign Affairs and International Trade (Canada).
In addition to the government sites, you should check out reputable news sources and get updates from travellers on the ground. The Thorn Tree is an excellent place to get firsthand accounts of the situation for travellers (see for example this post on the developing situation in Tunisia from January and this ongoing thread on the Japan earthquake and tsunami).
If you do decide to go based on all available information, it’s wise to take out an appropriate travel-insurance policy.
2. Why are you going?
This is a more philosophical question, but it will have profound effects for your trip.
If you’re looking for a stress-free holiday, you’ll want to reconsider your plans. Even after a disaster has passed, affected areas are usually engaged in rebuilding and adjusting. This will cause a degree of chaos and unpredictability. Choosing an alternative destination may be the best option (For those second-guessing their Cairo visit, UK travel editor Tom Hall recently wrote a guide to Egypt alternatives).
If you’re looking for adventure and a chance to connect with locals, then proceeding with your trip is a possibility. However, you still need to consider your motivation. Visiting a place in the aftermath of calamity may be thrilling, but is it appropriate? You may want to balance your penchant for excitement with respect for the people who will be serving as your hosts. It may be the case that delaying your trip will provide as much adventure while avoiding the negatives associated with ‘dark tourism‘.
3. Do your hosts want you there?
An easy way to answer ‘Should I go?’ is to ask ‘Do people want me there?’ This is where tapping into local networks – whether on Facebook, Twitter, blogs or elsewhere – can be invaluable. Are locals encouraging visitors (see Queensland, Australia, whose leader is actively courting visitors)? Are tourism boards planning campaigns (see Egypt, whose Tourism Minister is trying to invite Oprah along)? Are airlines offering sweetheart deals to lure back travellers?
If the answer to most of these questions is ‘no’, you might consider postponing your trip to a more appropriate time.
4. How flexible is your itinerary?
This decision is based purely on cost and convenience. If you have a flexible airline ticket that allows you to change date, or if you purchased a strong insurance policy, you can often move your travel dates. This is often the best solution – if your personal circumstances allow for it.
If you are locked into a travel schedule, your insurance company should be able to help. You may be able to book an alternative holiday to a nearby destination. (Take for example New Zealand’s South Island, where the centre of Christchurch was devastated by an earthquake that left the entire surrounding area virtually undisturbed.)
In the worst-case scenario, you may have to request refunds for all your travel bookings and begin planning your next vacation. While this can feel disappointing, keep in mind that safety and respect are higher priorities!
5. What’s the best way to help?
Every year, thousands upon thousands of well-meaning travellers head around the world in order to help. What many don’t realise is that often it’s actually harmful to replace low-paid, skilled local labour with unpaid, unskilled foreign labour. Dealing with an influx of visitors wandering around asking ‘What can I do?’ can add stress and overhead to a relief effort.
If you want to help, do your research. Often, the best way to start is by donating to an emergency fund whose mission you believe in and whose methods you trust.
If you have your heart set on on-the-ground volunteering, make sure that you sign up with a well-organised outfit that will prepare and train you adequately, ensuring that your destination benefits from your assistance. For more information, read Lonely Planet’s tips for responsible volunteering.
Keep up to date with the latest news from travellers on the Thorn Tree forum.
Comments
-
9 March 2011 6:34PM
dphrph
Report this comment
I remember two situations dealing with the situation. Shortly after the tsunami hit Sri Lanka, a travel writer was interviewing inhabitants of a village that had been expanding it's small tourism trade. They keep saying that they wanted people to come and visit as they wouldn't have any money to keep repairing damage if nobody came.
The second situation was after the earthquake in Haiti. Some of the cruise ship companies were under fire for continuing to stop at a port in the north of the country. The Haitians who worked at the port were upset that some organizations/media were shaming the cruise lines into skipping the country. The workers were complaining that they would have no jobs and income to help their families etc if nobody came. The north of the country was untouched by the earthquake.
I wouldn't go while there are still search and rescue operations going on, but if the region is rebuilding and hoping for travelers, then I'd go.
-
10 March 2011 1:34AM
vasenka
Report this comment
Disasters and Civil Unrest are usually localized... not across an entire city...or country.
If a city is having civil disturbances it is often in the government district...but the side streets and suburbs could be totally unaffected...
People entering these conflict zones do so at their own risk...and "going native" to some extent is probably advisable.
If the unrest or disaster closes down the outlying areas...or the banks and the airports are closed...it would be best to avoid the area... or have back up plans to deal with the situation...
Disaster reporting and Disaster Relief is acceptable...
But Disaster Tourism...? I don't think so.
Add a comment
Yemen
Things to do
- All things to do (69)
- Activities (3)
- Entertainment (5)
- Restaurants (19)
- Shopping (9)
- Sights (33)
- Tours (0)









