restaurants / Pizzeria

Totonno’s information

New York City , USA
Street 1524 Neptune Ave
Extras cnr 16th St, Coney Island
+1 718 372 8606
Getting there
subway D/F, N/Q to Coney Island-Stillwell Ave
pizza $17-20
Opening hours
noon-8pm Wed-Sun
Something wrong?
Submit a correction

Lonely Planet review

This old-school pizza parlor is open daily – as long as there’s fresh dough. The toppings menu is slim (check the board above the open kitchen), but this is the kind of pie that doesn’t need lots of overwrought decoration: coal-fired dough is topped with mozzarella first, followed by tomato sauce, so your crust never gets soggy. A place of pilgrimage, complete with real-deal New York attitude.