go to content go to search box go to global site navigation

Thorn Tree Forum

Israeli stamp makes Malaysia travel difficult?

Replies: 25 - Last Post: Jun 4, 2007 12:33 PM Last Post By: patrick0

jump to
← Back to topic list

chicarica72

chicarica72 avatar

Aug 3, 2004 7:05 PM
Posts:  2

Israeli stamp makes Malaysia travel difficult?

I know: boring question. Yes, I did phone the Malaysian embassy in my country, but I'm still not sure if it's a good idea to visit Malaysia with an Israeli passport stamp in my Dutch passport.

Anyone have the same stamp and went or try to enter Malaysia? I'd really appreciate to know about your experience. Thanks you helping out.

westwood

westwood avatar

Aug 3, 2004 8:43 PM
Posts:  8,846

1

#1, not disputingt what you say, but on all the times I've entered malaysia overland, the immigration guys just look at the front page and then flip to the last page where I leave my departure card.

kiteflyer88

kiteflyer88 avatar

Aug 3, 2004 10:19 PM
Posts:  3

2

ILoveAsia, please indicate where you found your information. You've stated this opinion several times, but yet haven't responded to my requests for verification.

I have e-mailed Malyasian and Indonesian Consulates in several countries, and all of them, without exception, have responded in the same way - an Israeli stamp makes no difference whatsoever for entry to either of these countries.

Further, none of the airlines flying to either of these countries checks for an Israeli stamp, and they would definitely be responsible for your transport if you were refused entry.

On none of my visits to either Malaysia or Indonesia has any Immigration officer looked thru my passport, except to find a place to place the entry stamp.

If there is anyone out there that has DEFINITE information one way or the other, please post here, or drop me a PM.....Thanks.....JP

jude151

jude151 avatar

Aug 4, 2004 1:44 AM
Posts:  6

3

Every year, hundreds, maybe thousands of Singaporeans visit Israel as tourists. Singapore has diplomatic relations with Israel. And every month, hundreds of thousands Singaporeans cross the borders to Malaysia and Indonesia. I have yet to come across a single report of any Singaporean being barred from these two countries because of an Israeli passport stamp. In short, it will not be a problem!

ariari

ariari avatar

Aug 4, 2004 8:17 AM
Posts:  4

4

I think Iloveasia is being overly alarmist. By the way, `tidak bisa masuk' is an Indonesian phrase and not a Malaysian one. A Malaysian would say `tidak boleh masuk'. But...since you love Asia, you're forgiven.

kiteflyer88

kiteflyer88 avatar

Aug 4, 2004 9:35 AM
Posts:  3

5

ILoveAsia, are you able to provide documentation, examples, or definite instances of anyone being refused entry to either Malaysia or Indonesia because of an Israeli stamp in their passport?

You seem to be quite insistent, so clearly you must have information that eludes the rest of us. Please share it. JP Harrison

daycat

daycat avatar

Aug 4, 2004 12:51 PM
Posts:  7,744

6

Only Non entry, or entry with severe conditions, is that if you hold an Israeli Passport.

Just an entry stamp in your passport that you have visited Israel, does not make a difference.

And what one of the posters said, they don't look at other pages except the front page, to scan, and the one, where they stamp, where you place the embarkation card is true.

Ps. Malaysian Immi does not stamp pages in order. You will find their entry stamp, they may/can stamp an entry visa stamp, many pages, even after some empty pages.

Ps. If you have a new Euro passport, it might just be scanned! And, not chopped, (stamped) unless you ask for it.

ST88

ST88 avatar

Aug 5, 2004 12:51 AM
Posts:  4

7

#9 "chopped".....as in karate? just kidding but it would be a funny sight to see officers karate-chopping passports.

BTW, Aussie immigration officers also stamp randomly! I had one on the last page of my passport even though it was a new passport at that time.

ndut

ndut avatar

Aug 5, 2004 2:35 AM
Posts:  1,387

8

naaah... i think you should be alright.
act normal (no matter how hard it is for you :p), and enjoy the journey.
as long as you have the return ticket, you should be all set

ariari

ariari avatar

Aug 5, 2004 7:44 AM
Posts:  4

9

Iloveasia, you come down from a plane in New York, go to immigration, and the officer there goes "G'dday mate!". Is this OK with you?? You tell me.....

TigerTraveller

TigerTraveller avatar

Aug 5, 2004 10:40 AM
Posts:  12

10

Actually - I think it should be OK.

I travelled with a friend to Malaysia & she had been to israel/egypt a few years before.

snailtrailer

snailtrailer avatar

Aug 5, 2004 2:14 PM
Posts:  3

11

iloveasia maybe indo man for speaking funny english...
explains why him give strong anti advice... ;)

Anyway, you can always ripp out that page from your passport...
besides I guess it is Israelis with their passports that are refused in Indonesia ?
(sothat any Israeli there is there with a US or UK passport..).

snailtrailer

snailtrailer avatar

Aug 5, 2004 2:15 PM
Posts:  3

12

..and malysia is more developed than indonesia..so my guess is there is no problem

travelbore

travelbore avatar

Aug 5, 2004 8:07 PM
Posts:  4

13

I visited Malaysia twice with my old passport that had a load of Israeli stamps - no problems.

Don't advise tearing a page out of a passport though. Pages are numbered and tearing one out could cause a lot of hassle if noticed. It might even invalidate your passport.

kiteflyer88

kiteflyer88 avatar

Aug 6, 2004 3:37 AM
Posts:  3

14

May I summarize?

ILoveAsia believes that you can't enter Malaysia with an Israeli stamp in your passport, but refuses (or is unable) to provide specific examples. He/she continues to say the same thing, in spite of several posters noting that they have had no problems, in spite of denials by the authorities, and in spite of denials by the airlines.

Therefore, I conclude that his "information" is nonsense. Of course, if anyone has direct experience to the contrary, I would be pleased if you could post here, or PM me directly, so that I can add accurate information to the visa thread.

JP Harrison
← Back to topic list
ADVERTISEMENT

In our shop

See all shop products

Hotels & Hostels

See all hotels & hostels