go to content go to search box go to global site navigation

Thorn Tree Forum

Voluntourism with a twist

Replies: 14 - Last Post: Jan 25, 2013 4:21 AM Last Post By: lukemackin

jump to
← Back to topic list

milliecaddy

milliecaddy avatar

Jan 22, 2013 10:19 PM
Posts:  2

Voluntourism with a twist

I recently visited Cianjur in west java through the home stay program recommended by lonely planet and although i was quite unimpressed with the program I met some very interesting people along the way. One of who was Hadi Sutrisno who is the principle of the local hospitality school there. He informed me about a program starting up first of its kind that actually works with inmates in the local jails (mostly in their for petty crimes) and teaches English and a diploma in hotel studies to enable them future prospects when they are released. I unfortunately was not staying long enough to partake in this program (as it is not starting until next week) but took great interest. I spent time with hadi and his family and they are fantastic people who all speak very good english. If interested in this program Hadi is more than willing to provide accomodation in his family home as well transport etc to and from the jail. The program will run 3 days a week and there is no minimum time you must stay. TEFL course qualifications are not required but would be ideal. Anyone interested in this can either email Hadi at- hadi_strisno@yahoo.com or telephone him on +62263266455.
I highly recommend this for anyone who is interested in making a difference during their travels and also for those who want to get to know life in a non touristy indonesian town

dc1

dc1 avatar

Jan 23, 2013 12:00 AM
Posts:  672

1

great to hear of this program.

..but even as a voluntary program it can't be done within a tourist visa, can it??

Would the program assist with the relevant visa for this... i would be very interested long term if they do.

sitiamina

sitiamina avatar

Jan 23, 2013 2:08 AM
Posts:  178

2

NOT possible to do voluntary work on a tourist visa. Against the law. Can be very costly if found out.
A working visa is very expensive and how would it be possible for the program to pay for that, as I understand it's the man Hadi who has initiated it.

dc1

dc1 avatar

Jan 23, 2013 2:29 AM
Posts:  672

3

I agree sitiamina, in both parts... i was going for the more gentle approach :-)

OP - we're not trying to put a downer on this - just safeguarding those who may spend time looking into this.. and even taking part in the program while on a non-working (whether paid or not) toursit visa..... immigration laws are there to be obeyed... a foreign person who is caught doing this type of work on a tourist visa would be in serious trouble if it went as far as court time.

pPamela

pPamela avatar

Jan 23, 2013 11:24 AM
Posts:  425

4

Have to agree - one has to be very careful being involved with programmes like this without the relevant visa.

YumSeng

YumSeng avatar

Jan 24, 2013 1:06 PM
Posts:  136

5

Long term might be a problem but for a few days, less than a week, it shouldnt be.
My friends from Singapore regularly join volunteer programmes, not this specific one, in an unofficial way on tourist visa. They spent their time with friends of friends "talking " in English and these friends provide free accomodation and food, as most Indonesian friends do. Technically theres no money involved. They have not stayed longer than a week at any particular time.

dc1

dc1 avatar

Jan 24, 2013 6:34 PM
Posts:  672

6

I agree YumSeng, living at a homestay and talking to friends of friends in a non structured learning environment (learning each others languages and cultures) is probably okay, let's face it we've all done this at some point of our travels while in Indonesia (but i would personally never do it if it was part of a volunteer program).. but to be part of the type of program highlighted with the opening post goes against the immigration laws.

For the benefit of people who are heading to Indonesia for the first time; to work even as a volunteer (non money making) while in the country on a tourist visa contravenes that visa.

lukemackin

lukemackin avatar

Jan 24, 2013 9:00 PM
Posts:  206

7

Curious if anyone has any links to government laws that state short-term volunteer tourism is not allowed on a VOA.

sitiamina

sitiamina avatar

Jan 24, 2013 11:24 PM
Posts:  178

8

No links to government laws but if you read up on the visa regulations is states very clearly that you can NOT work on any kind of visa except a work visa and that requires a KITA. Volontary work is equalled with a normal job. There is no such thing as a volunteer tourism visa, so no way around the regulations. Many does volontary work anyhow but it's not legal. If found out a person can be brought to court, have to pay heavy fines and then face deportation.

milliecaddy

milliecaddy avatar

Jan 25, 2013 1:38 AM
Posts:  2

9

this is a very new and localised program I really cant see you getting found out volunteering on a tourist visa with a program like this but i suppose better to be safe than sorry

pPamela

pPamela avatar

Jan 25, 2013 1:54 AM
Posts:  425

10

Well, if someone wants to report the volunteer traveller to the authorities, there is nothing to stop them doing so and there might be all sorts of motivations for someone to do that.
Pamela

YumSeng

YumSeng avatar

Jan 25, 2013 2:40 AM
Posts:  136

11

Curious to know if anyone had personal experience of getting in trouble, big or small, while doing short-term volunteering.

lukemackin

lukemackin avatar

Jan 25, 2013 2:55 AM
Posts:  206

12

Sitiamina, do you have those visa regulations handy somewhere? I'd really like to read them over.

Is short-term volunteer tourism really equal with a normal job in the eyes of the law? How do you know this?

lukemackin

lukemackin avatar

Jan 25, 2013 4:16 AM
Posts:  206

13

Found the 2010 (new) version here, although it's not as defined as I would like. http://www.kemenkumham.go.id/attachments/article/143/M.HH-01.GR.01.06%20Tahun%202010.pdf
A clearer copy here: http://www.expat.or.id/info/VisaKunjunganSaatKedatanganbn12-2010.pdf

"Visa on Arrivals can be granted to foreign citizens who intend to visit Indonesia for tourism, social and cultural visits, business visits, or governmental duties, considering the foundation of being mutually beneficial, and not posing a security threat." (that's my poor translation attempt)

I feel like volunteering short-term would fall somewhere within a social-cultural or even business definition if you're a stickler, right? So, I'm still curious why VOAs aren't good enough for short-term volunteering, and if they aren't, which visa would be?

lukemackin

lukemackin avatar

Jan 25, 2013 4:21 AM
Posts:  206

14

Here's another link:
http://www.deplu.go.id/Pages/ServiceDisplay.aspx?IDP=7&IDP2=21&Name=ConsularService&l=en

"This visa can be obtained directly when you arrive at certain airports and seaports in Indonesia, regardless of the purpose of your visit (Business, Tourist, Social-Cultural)."

Again, why isn't volunteering allowed?
← Back to topic list
ADVERTISEMENT

In our shop

See all shop products

Hotels & Hostels

See all hotels & hostels