1

I enjoyed every one of my 5 days in Utila, though I dived only thrice. I walked around, kayaked (free if staying at Alton's) and hung out at Alton's, a stimulating place. They got everything you need there, not to mention a captive breeding conch corral.
Alternatively, you could hit Sambo Creek, where you can stay at Hotel Centroturistico, that has a fine bar and restaurant on a deck overlooking the beach. Every morning there are boats going to Cayos Cochinos. Most people do it as a day trip, but I met some dudes who stayed there several nights. Sambo is about a half hour bus ride east of La Ceiba. Tell Mauricio Eddy sent you.
I stayed 3 nights at Omega Lodge last January. Look that up. It suited me.
D&D Brewery, 1.5 hr S of San Pedro, I highly recommend (as long as you dont partake of their fruited-up beer).

2

And I wish people would quit using the term "must see". As a general rule, who am I to say what someone "must see". Of course there are exceptions to everything: for instance, fruited-up beer is a "must NOT guzzle" item.

3

I wish people would stop asking if it is worth it. Worth has to be according to individual taste or it wouldn't be worth anything.

4

Fair enough, I probably could have phrased that a bit differently. I guess I'll just see when I get there.

Thanks for the responses :)

5

Go to Nica, Bay Islands is a lot of time and effort IMO, unless you have unlimited time.

Must NOT see...San JUan Del Sur Nicaragua...hehe