go to content go to search box go to global site navigation

Thorn Tree Forum

Train travel

Replies: 16 - Last Post: Oct 11, 2012 6:06 AM Last Post By: Grahamapoole

jump to
← Back to topic list

patriciatbrogan

patriciatbrogan avatar

Oct 7, 2012 5:04 PM
Posts:  195

Train travel

when travelling by train during the day and wishing to see out and appreciate the views, my impression from what I have read on this website is that it would be better to book a seat in a 2nd-class compartment as one can see outside, whereas travelling in the aircon compartments the windows prevent one from seeing and appreciating the outlook/ view - is that correct?

I assume, travelling at night one would book an aircom compartment?

I would appreciate any comments and advice, thanks.

joegoozey

joegoozey avatar

Oct 7, 2012 6:34 PM
Posts:  1,618

1

That is correct. AC compartment windows are sealed and blacked out. You can stil see out, but it's 'dark' ... very dark.

zoltan

zoltan avatar

Oct 7, 2012 8:46 PM
Posts:  800

2

The windows in AC coaches are often not cleaned; are sometimes scratched and visibility can definitely be an issue.

As for traveling at night, whether to book an AC coach or not, depends largely on when and where you are traveling.

Sometimes being in SL coaches can be just as good as AC. If you are going during the winter months (ie. cold), then definitely book an AC coach, if for no other reason than not to have the biting chills hitting you in the night.

If it's the hot season, then the only real concerns are mosquitoes and whether it's too hot for you to bear.

nevinpowers7

nevinpowers7 avatar

Oct 7, 2012 10:50 PM
Posts:  73

3

I agree with #2. It all depends on the weather. And if its raining, fellow passengers would ask you to close the windows (incase you don't do it yourself ) and then 2nd class would turn into a nightmare. These Ac coaches aren't all that bad and I've never found it very difficult to see what's happening outside. Sometimes you get terribly unlucky ( scratch/dirt ) but you can't do anything about it. You might get terribly unlucky in 2nd class as well.
And let me stress on this point, 2nd class compartments and sleeper coaches can be different things. ONLY take the latter. Never opt for the 'general' coach.
If you have the money, take 3rd AC. That according to me is the best way to travel in India.

calpu

calpu avatar

Oct 7, 2012 11:13 PM
Posts:  110

4

Agreed with 2&3... But i feel, if its a short trip take sleeper class...otherwise travel in acII/III...if u mind about a little more safety..cleaner toilets etc... Otherwise, who cares...nothing gonna stay forever...not the heat,dust,cold,irritation etc.etc.etc...just ignore all with a deep smile....:)
stay safe...

xscorcho

xscorcho avatar

Oct 8, 2012 1:11 AM
Posts:  52

5

by "second class" i hope you are referring to "sleeper class (SL)" and not actual 'II class".

II class is a free for all and there are no seat reservations.
sleeper class has seat reservations.

you can see out of the windows for both.

i've never travelled any of the a\c classes bcoz i always get sick in a\c so no experience with those, but from the outside of the train it looks like the windows are frosted.

took II class once - don't recommend it unless you have no other option. i was lucky i could go in the "women's compartment" otherwise i think it would have been a complete nightmare!!

cowantimmy12

cowantimmy12 avatar

Oct 8, 2012 2:36 AM
Posts:  798

6

are you sure you want to see what is out the window
you may regret having a clear view
have a book for daytime
flask of whiskey for nighttime

patriciatbrogan

patriciatbrogan avatar

Oct 8, 2012 2:40 AM
Posts:  195

7

Haha! It's nice to see the lovely countryside, especially the lush south, I remember when I was last on this train in the 1970`s - definitely take a book, good suggestion: whiskey (beer for me) at night!

Grahamapoole

Grahamapoole avatar

Oct 8, 2012 7:08 AM
Posts:  1,294

8

Just one further point - there is a far better chance of the lavvies being kept clean in the AC classes - just a chance - your property is likely to be more secure.
Finally there is a good chance that you'll meet up with well-educated Indians with whom you can not only converse but learn - possibly the best bit of train travel - the only time that you can seriously meet a local in anuncompliacted way.

ZedisDead

ZedisDead avatar

Oct 8, 2012 10:02 AM
Posts:  305

9

I had a find tine ion A/C 2, meeting mant very nice Indian families

dreamsignals86

dreamsignals86 avatar

Oct 9, 2012 11:14 AM
Posts:  2,114

10

If you are in AC, you can still go stand by the door to the train and look out from there.

I usually travel sleeper class (at night too). Sometimes it can get chilly at night, but if you have a sleeping bag (or even buy one of those big wool blankets most Indians bring on the trains), I don't find it to be that bad. I generally prefer the adventure of sleeper class.

bvsprasanna

bvsprasanna avatar

Oct 10, 2012 1:03 AM
Posts:  69

11

Recommend a AC coach for the sake of cleanliness, safety and comfort. As said in #10, you may always stand by the door or even venture out to the other compartments and share a seat if available and be back to the AC as and when you want to rest.

nijkerk

nijkerk avatar

Oct 10, 2012 3:51 AM
Posts:  1,602

12

Only travelled AC First Class once, from Jhansi to Delhi....no other choice except for 2 class unreserved...no thanks, been there , done that.. It was September and no need for the ac .. but it was set to ""very cold"" and we needed the blankets....the windows were dark and very dirty ..as were the toilets.

dreamsignals86

dreamsignals86 avatar

Oct 10, 2012 5:07 AM
Posts:  2,114

13

To be clear, I was talking about 3 Tier AC

calpu

calpu avatar

Oct 11, 2012 12:51 AM
Posts:  110

← Back to topic list
ADVERTISEMENT

In our shop

Bags feeling light?
Coffee table looking bare?
Get your guidebooks, travel goods, even individual chapters, right here.

See all books in our shop

Hotels & Hostels

See all hotels & hostels