go to content go to search box go to global site navigation

Thorn Tree Forum

Why the anti-Bali bias from Lonely Planet Indonesia Writer?

Replies: 93 - Last Post: May 30, 2012 5:09 PM Last Post By: dude_Copronymus

jump to
← Back to topic list

salud

salud avatar

May 23, 2012 8:03 PM
Posts:  173

30

Well if you spent time in "Sumatera" ,you should be at the very least least be able to spell it properly. You are not even close. Try the 'spell-check' .function---Duh

lukemackin

lukemackin avatar

May 23, 2012 8:12 PM
Posts:  206

31

I really hope you're making a joke, salud.

HenningWessel

HenningWessel avatar

May 23, 2012 8:12 PM
Posts:  2,357

32

"Tourists" stay in Bali - "travellers" go east.
Ha, ha, ha.

Bebik (something like that)
Bebek.

MadeIndra

MadeIndra avatar

May 23, 2012 8:59 PM
Posts:  1,736

33

@31, I guess we know for sure that Salud isn't Indonesian, eh? ;<)

dougv

dougv avatar

May 23, 2012 9:14 PM
Posts:  355

34

I still enjoy Bali. I don't know nearly as much about the Balinese as I should and even less about the Island than I could, but then, now I usually go to Bali after going to other places in Indonesia to relax for a while, enjoy a better tourist infrastructure and and shop for all my favorite wooden boxes, and other fun stuff in the marketplaces. I have been there enough not to get too skinned by the vendors, I like to bargain, I don't get bent out of shape by paying more than the "locals" and I like all the activity in places like Ubud. I don't really care that I have watched Bali change (modernize) since I first went in 1998 - the Balinese seem to do their thing regardless and don't seem too concerned with what anyone else thinks about their culture, ceremonies and lifestyle anyway. Besides, modernization is not such a bad thing for anyone who wants to improve their lives and living conditions and even with modernization, I still have a hard time describing Indonesia to anyone in the States who has never been there.
I have also struggled in other parts of Indonesia (Sumatra, parts of Java, Suluwesi, etc.)
and accept what those adventures had to offer. They are all different - and even primitive at times by my standards as an American tourist. But in order to find fascinating places I have to adapt and keep an open mind as best I can.
Bali is what it is, and I probably only know a little bit about what it really is about. But then that's Indonesia - endlessly fascinating, never static, constantly surprising, kind of crazy, often bewildering and still a little - or in other places a lot - rough around the edges.
I think I wandered a bit. Not sure I said what I meant, only that I meant what I said.. Oh yeah, as for LP guidebooks, they are helpful, and have pretty pictures, but definitely not the "bible."

lucapal

lucapal avatar

May 24, 2012 12:15 AM
Posts:  10,681

35

I still enjoy it too....as I said above.And i'm happy if the Balinese decide for themselves,rather than other Indonesians or foreigners.

I'm glad that geedivine has changed their opinion considerably from what they said in the first post,which was rubbish.

That is....Bali was an expensive destination in the past,that has become cheaper.This is clearly not true...even people who think it is a good thing (like MadeIndra)admit that Bali has become steadily more upmarket and more expensive.

And...that going to places like Papua or Maluku will cost you 'a thousand dollars a day'...that is patent rubbish.

lucapal

lucapal avatar

May 24, 2012 12:31 AM
Posts:  10,681

36

Personally,I will continue to do as I have done before..

That is...explore parts of Indonesia where I can travel cheaply and see great beaches,wildlife,go trekking,learn about different cultures....then come to Bali to relax in 'luxury'for a few days (carefully avoiding Kuta,Legian and all of that area).

I suggest any traveller considering Indonesia does the same.........

salud

salud avatar

May 24, 2012 12:49 AM
Posts:  173

37

i posted on the wrong site, find and read, it was about the Bali thread, no further explanation is of no use to someone like you #33

salud

salud avatar

May 24, 2012 1:17 AM
Posts:  173

38

Eh, would that be Canuck?

MadeIndra

MadeIndra avatar

May 24, 2012 2:31 AM
Posts:  1,736

39

Nah, it's Mexican. Nice try with #37. Your post #30 is precisely where you wanted it.

salud

salud avatar

May 24, 2012 2:43 AM
Posts:  173

40

Viva la Mexico

chrisdurn

chrisdurn avatar

May 24, 2012 9:16 AM
Posts:  46

41

Bali's got those, 'Balinese' people. Until that changes - it's gonna be a place to visit.

salud

salud avatar

May 24, 2012 5:36 PM
Posts:  173

42

yes ,Bali should be on anyone's 'shortlist as well as many others, but I will not reveal them. I always want to be the one that locks the gate

dude_Copronymus

dude_Copronymus avatar

May 24, 2012 11:20 PM
Posts:  29

43

Well when it was Indonesia Handbook, you didn't have the riff raff you have now.

That said, Tony Wheeler himself said "We are all tourists now" and that 10 years ago.

No need to cry just leave your pith helmets at the door.

HenningWessel

HenningWessel avatar

May 24, 2012 11:31 PM
Posts:  2,357

44

This branch has more multi- nicks that the Vietnam branch, I notice :)
← Back to topic list
ADVERTISEMENT

In our shop

See all shop products

Hotels & Hostels

See all hotels & hostels