Thorn Tree travel forum

The Classics

Replies: 16 - Last Post: 10-Jun-2007 11:41 Last Post By: Websterella

jump to

ANITAROSE

ANITAROSE avatar

17-May-2007 06:20
Posts:  502

The Classics

Well my boys are almost out of school for the summer and I told them they would have to pick 3 books each and read them for the summer. My uncle told me to tell them to read the "classics"...well he can't remember what they are and I have no idea what the hell he is talking about.

Now the boys read last summer, "Three Muskateers", "Around the World in 80 Days", "20,000 Leagues Under the Sea"...I thought those were classic books.

Well if anyone can make any suggestions I would greatly appreciate it. Oh the boys are 12 and 11.

CrazyEddie

CrazyEddie avatar

17-May-2007 06:35
Posts:  1,021

1

Robinson Crusoe
Tom Sawyer & Huckleberry Finn (2 closely-connected books, but you can probably get them in one volume)
Treasure Island
The Coral Island
The Hobbit

...and still they gazed, and still the wonder grew...

ethelred

ethelred avatar

17-May-2007 07:26
Posts:  7,266

2

Let them choose which ones to read, rather than forcing them to read "classics" or any other type of literature. If the goal is for them to understand how fun reading is, and how it can teach you things and transport you to other worlds, they have to be reading something that catches their individual interest. Maybe that will end up being one of the classics, and maybe it won't.

Take them to the library to browse... doesn't cost anything to check out 2 or 3 books and decide to read only one of them, depending on your mood at the time.

If they learn to love reading, they'll eventually WANT to read the classics -- if they learn reading is a chore, they'll read only what they have to and stop there.

Rossam

Rossam avatar

17-May-2007 08:00
Posts:  350

3

To Kill a Mocking Bird

"To live in one land is captivity"

"This is the patent age of new inventions for killing bodies, and for saving souls. All propagated with the best intentions"

Brad Pitt + Einstein = Dick Cheney

Usher73

Usher73 avatar

17-May-2007 09:53
Posts:  2,195

4


Two Years Before the Mast

The Count of Monte Cristo

Gulliver's Travels

Tales of Mystery and Imagination, Edgar Allan Poe

maybe not known as classics, but remarkable true stories:
Shackleton by Roland Huntford
Endurance by Alfred Lansing

jimcowdrill

jimcowdrill avatar

17-May-2007 10:32
Posts:  10,050

5

Quote

If they learn to love reading, they'll eventually WANT to read the classics
I love reading and I haven't yet... but overall, I agree with ethelred. The Hobbit and To Kill A Mockingbird are great books - and I loved My Family and Other Animals at about that age - but they're old enough to make their own decisions in these matters.

www.travbuddy.com/jimcowdrill/blogs

zebec

zebec avatar

17-May-2007 17:52
Posts:  897

6

Canadian kids author and former teacher Paul Kropp, has an essential book called 'How to Make Your Kid a Reader For Life'. I have never seen a better organized, more comprehensive yet user-friendly listing of the 'classics' old and new. So outstanding, that when the Literacy Consultant visited the school where I teach and complained in an aside to me how his young daughter seems allergic to books, this was the first title I recommended. See also, anything by Mary Tarasoff for 'alternatives to book reports'---young readers must have the chance to express some sort of personal reaction to inform their comprehension.
Apparently there is a website for youths wherein readers can submit their on-line book report opinions. Perhaps a Google might dig it up....?

starflyer59

starflyer59 avatar

17-May-2007 18:07
Posts:  3,698

7

100 Books recommended by the College Board, for "college-bound readers."

All of the suggestions in #1, along with To Kill A Mockingbird, would be great for children of those ages.

Also agree with short stories by Poe. I think I got hooked on literature by reading through collections of short stories-- Poe and Jack London were favorites when I was around your boys' ages.

Crane, Stephen: The Red Badge of Courage

London, Jack The Call of the Wild

Cooper, James Fenimore: The Last of the Mohicans

A more modern choice would be Bridge to Terabithia, by Katherine Paterson. A new movie is out on it, which I haven't seen.

Also-- C.S. Lewis' Chronicals of Narnia series might make lovely classic summer reading for your boys.

"Once your reputation is ruined, you can live life quite freely."

zebec

zebec avatar

17-May-2007 19:58
Posts:  897

8

Cue to an appearance made at one of my old schools. Toronto Maple Leaf hockey stars showed up as part of our Literacy Week. A number of parents were so excited that they took the day off, showing up with videocams, packing the gym. Once the players were seated and given a michrophone, a young girl was the first to ask them a question.
"What was your fave book that you read recently?"
Leaf vet Darcy Tucker answered and completely without irony said, "I don't read many books."

CrazyEddie

CrazyEddie avatar

18-May-2007 01:14
Posts:  1,021

9

Quote

London, Jack The Call of the Wild


And "White Fang" of course.

King Solomon's mines

...and still they gazed, and still the wonder grew...

ethelred

ethelred avatar

18-May-2007 06:22
Posts:  7,266

10

#8 ... too funny.

stalky

stalky avatar

18-May-2007 15:07
Posts:  57

11

ooo. well i was a geeky child (of course as opposed to being a geeky adult). I loved stalky and co by kipling, anything by s e hinton.
...

listen i would say try and look at what they enjoy doing and see if you can find a book that's related to that. it will help them get into it, because i'm guessing they're not huge readers if you need to have this policy. Me, my parents would have loved it i think if i had read a little less!!!

(and if you give some more ideas, as opposed to just age i would happily provide further options.) a lot of the books i would recomend might be a bit old fashioned for them.

Another thing to think about is maybe choosing at least one book (or suggesting, agree you shouldn't FORCE them to read) that has been made into a movie. You could say lets read the book then see the movie and tell me what you liked best.

And maybe even allow a graphic novel. i guess the maus books are a little too graphic for kids that age, but they are amazing. and educational. but sad too.

Do you like Kipling?
I don´t know, I´ve never kippled before.

LoungeSinger

LoungeSinger avatar

18-May-2007 22:51
Posts:  58

12

Homer - The Odyssey
Douglas Adams - The Hitchiker's Guide to the Galaxy
The Book of One Thousand and One Nights (also known as "Arabian Nights")

"Drinking is the joy of the Slav!" -Vladimir I, Prince of Kiev

Bothsidesnow

Bothsidesnow avatar

20-May-2007 09:43
Posts:  123

13

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle stories - short stories are sometimes more manageable than novels.

The Chronicles of Narnia are always a great read.

Huck Finn.

the Hobbit

I really don't know clouds at all

Scrubb

Scrubb avatar

22-May-2007 16:03
Posts:  11,766

14

Some of the suggestions are great, but please don't force them to read Robinson Crusoe, The Count of Monte Cristo, The Red Badge of Courage, or Gulliver's Travels at their ages.

I was an extremely keen reader as a kid (got 5 books from the library every single Saturday of my childhood and returned them all, read, the following week) and I've always enjoyed classics, but the originals of the 4 books I mentioned above would have been unbearable at that age. (Well, Monte Cristo might have been okay but it's extremely long - doesn't seem fair to have a several-hundred-page long one on the list.)

nycfellow: "Scrubb is clearly the voice of authority"

Your Recent Threads

 
RSS Subscribe to all

Announcements

  1. Avatars!

    Posted By: VenessaP -- 28-Jan-2010 15:01

  2. How would you improve Thorn...

    Posted By: VenessaP -- 09-Dec-2009 17:01

 
ADVERTISEMENT

Popular Travel Interests

 

WorldGuide is our online guide to the world - you name it, we cover it. Explore the richest source of global travel content on the web and let it fire your imagination.
more »

 
Thumb

Irish Language & Culture Travel Guide

Bejaysus and begorrah! The next best thing for anyone not blessed with the gift of the gab - a grand tour through the language...buy it »

 
 

Booking hotels is simple with Lonely Planet. See our reviewed and recommended hotels and book online.