Thorn Tree travel forum

pad thai and pointlessness

Replies: 8 - Last Post: 10-Mar-2008 20:03 Last Post By: miketa

jump to

Posted
06-Mar-2008 21:01
by: p_mc_livin

Posts:  524
Registered:  07/12/07

pad thai and pointlessness

Event fit for a king serves up pad thai and pointlessness

By Tom Plate Seattle Times Syndicated Columnist

HONOLULU — Not every monarch is alike. It's true that many are mean and greedy and full of themselves, selfish squirrels who sock their ill-gotten gains beneath everyone's eyes overseas while sticking their political opponents into dark, dank prisons — or graves. But some are comparatively mild, even perhaps honestly patriotic. Britain's Elizabeth, the old girl, strikes one as a rather civilized queen if you have to live with a monarch, and Thailand's Bhumibol Adulyadej, Rama IX of the Chakri Dynasty, tends to get pretty pro-king media reviews as a nice-guy sort of King George III.

But the Thai royal image suffered a bit of a setback about a year and a half ago when seasoned Siamese observers detected the subtle claw of the otherwise humble King Bhumibol behind the shocking removal of a sitting prime minister in September 2006. The Thai military fronted for the king and did the dirty work, of course, removing the government of Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra while the PM was traveling abroad.

But while Thanksin himself was — and still is — no doubt a rogue and a demagogue, he had, in fact, gotten into office by honest election, not by brutal force; and the military government that was put in place while he cooled his heels abroad until his return to Thailand last month was of Burmese junta quality (incredibly incompetent).

And perhaps so the royal image burnishers of Siam felt the need to go into action to regain the PR momentum, and in fact they sure looked to be in fine form recently in a Honolulu hotel ballroom. There, the place was decked out almost like a set for "The King and I."

The only flavor missing was the dear king himself — the actual honoree for whom a fancy award was ordered up. But being 80, not even a magic carpet was going to be able to whisk him to the scene of the Asia Pacific Community Building Award proffered by the East West Center of Honolulu. So, standing in His Majesty's place, on behalf of her father, was Her Royal Highness Princess Maha Chakri Sirindhorn.

Her flowery speech, read to a bored audience — word for word — praising her father's many countless deeds, was preceded by an amazingly boring video on the good king's many good deeds. It was a weird scene.

Let me be clear. The East West Center, which organized the evening and gave the award to Adulyadej "in recognition of His Majesty's dedicated work toward the welfare of the people of Thailand," is no bad joint. It's certainly no front for the Pentagon or the CIA or anyone else. It does good and important work. As nonprofits tend to go, it's one of the kinder, gentler ones, sitting sunnily on the campus of the University of Hawaii in Manoa.

What's more, the East West Center has a solid history, going back nearly half a century, with the good king and his kingdom. And of course Thailand is no black sheep internationally, as far as U.S. foreign policy is concerned: It was a staunch ally during the bitter days of the threatening Soviet Union, and remains a good friend of the West.

And, like all nonprofits, the name of the game in survival is fundraising.

The significant and deep-pocketed Thai Diaspora undoubtedly appreciated the kingly toast Friday night, and funneled its spare change accordingly. As the evening was aboveboard and totally public, there is nothing wrong with that.

But even so, somehow the whole event left a taste in the mouth that one doesn't ordinarily associate with things Thai. Democracy is not the one-size-fits-all formula for all, and as mentioned, the elected Thaksin was no second coming of Thomas Jefferson. But removed as the PM had been by the force of arms, the East West Center's bow to the king seemed odd. One rests happily when American nonprofits honor geniuses or freedom fighters or even the otherwise disenfranchised. But kings — or queens, for that matter — would seem to need no honorific welfare from American nonprofits.

The East West Center is entitled to honor almost anyone it wants. But upon leaving the hall, one had to wonder why the king's handlers felt compelled to organize such an unnecessary and questionable event as this.

Why go out of your way to honor a king who allegedly is so wonderful he doesn't need any more honors? One had to wonder.

UCLA professor Tom Plate is a veteran author and journalist.

Posted
06-Mar-2008 22:46
by: Stupid_American

Posts:  1,540
Registered:  05/05/00

1

Another great insight!

For some Bangkok dining spots, check out Cheap Eats Bangkok

Posted
06-Mar-2008 23:58
by: dragonc

Posts:  365
Registered:  06/03/08

2

Another article written by a western journalist who obviously knows little about Thailand or its monarchy. The King is highly revered, and its not propaganda. Every one has pictures of him in their homes, and you see stickers on cars everywhere that say "We Love The King". The King is referred to as Father of the Nation.

Posted
06-Mar-2008 23:59
by: callippo

Posts:  6,135
Registered:  12/07/04

3

maybe Bhumimphol didn't bother turning up because he must know that the Thai monarchy doesn't come up on the US radar and didn't want people to draw comparisons with the UK Queen who got a good reception - and loads and loads of coverage on her trip to the United States last year as part the Jamestown 400th anniversary.

There were even times that she looked like she was actually enjoying herself too, rather than being the perenially
miserable git Bhumimphol's handlers insist he projects himself as being.

Americans have a bit of an obsession with monarchy, but monarchs that look Caucasian rather than Cantonese are usually going to feature higher up in the news.

Posted
07-Mar-2008 00:06
by: royalsmyth

Posts:  98
Registered:  05/02/08

4

mrs gorazdi's telegram was

@No mess monarch@
When informed you get 10 words for minimum 100Bhat she rejoindered

'No mess monarch !buffalo for sale. Old Irishman any offers?'

Posted
07-Mar-2008 00:48
by: Thailandagain

Posts:  18
Registered:  24/02/08

5

The journalist might have wanted to do a little research and look at other coup's in Thailand and whose support they have had as well.

As well as nod's and winks to the massacre of students at various times by army, police and right wing thugs.

Posted
07-Mar-2008 06:12
by: Hacky

Posts:  2,787
Registered:  10/09/03

6

Coup Save the King!

Yim nit-noi.

Posted
10-Mar-2008 19:55
by: miketa

Posts:  6
Registered:  11/02/08

7

A few of the posts here seem to come from people who are somewhat misinformed or uninformed re. Thai culture & society. I would suggest that, in order to get a clearer picture of the relationship of Rama IX to his people, they should do google searches on ; ; ; ; . New Mandala, the blog site of the Thai Studies people at A.N.U. is full of useful information & informed opinions from scholars and others who can speak with authority, including Thai political scientists. Some of these have personal experience of major events over the last 30+ years of Thai history, in which Bhumipol has been involved in various ways. A good place to start is their Interview with Paul Handley. There's also a very interesting thread following PM Samak's remarks on CNN and Al Jazeera recently. is a good keyword to search.

I hasten to add that coming to speedy conclusions about who's good & who's not in Thailand is not a good idea. It's a very complex & confusing place politically, fascinating & sometimes hilariously funny, to observe. Yes, of course it's the Land of Smiles! It's a good image - just don't believe it. And stay away from policemen. Especially friendly policemen.

dragonc #2: is there a point to your post? It's well known that Bhumipol is revered. What does that have to do with the article? Tom Plate, by the way, is a journalist & academic (UCLA) with many years' experience of the region.

Posted
10-Mar-2008 20:03
by: miketa

Posts:  6
Registered:  11/02/08

8

"especially friendly policemen" in my post #7 should be "especially drunken policemen."

Your Recent Threads

 
RSS Subscribe to all

Announcements

  1. Website speed - Facebook...

    Posted By: VenessaP -- 07-Oct-2009 16:30

 
ADVERTISEMENT

Popular Travel Interests

 

Thailand: Destination information

The Kingdom of Thailand draws more visitors than any other country in southeast Asia with its irresistible combination of breathtaking natural beauty, inspiring temples, renowned hospitality, robust c...more »

See » | Map »

 
Thumb

Thailand Travel Guide

Thailand blends the exotic with modern convenience: Bangkok is a gleaming city with a robust traditional...buy it »

 
 

Booking hotels is simple with Lonely Planet. See our reviewed and recommended hotels and book online.