Thorn Tree travel forum

Beware of Medical Tourism in Thailand

Replies: 7 - Last Post: 02-Nov-2009 17:53 Last Post By: teenutty

jump to

Posted
10-Feb-2007 20:07
by: HeatherTascal

Posts:  7
Registered:  26/01/07

Beware of Medical Tourism in Thailand

Beware of Medical Tourism in Thailand

See below letter I have sent to the US Embassy:

To the American Embassy, Bangkok, Thailand, U.S. Citizen's Services:

As an individual, my circumstances, and/or opinion may not be of any significance. But, I feel compelled to help guard my fellow Americans from the harmful experiences I was forced to endure as a medical tourist to Thailand from the United States.

Over a year ago, I dropped by the United States Embassy in Bangkok, to pick up a copy of the list of Attorneys that it compiles for Americans in Thailand seeking legal assistance. My reasons for doing so, had to do with me attempting to file a medical malpractice complaint against a Thai plastic surgeon that had badly scarred, mutilated, and disfigured my face. Please see the following brief description of this experience:

As an American, I have been scared, mutilated, and disfigured by offshore plastic surgery in Thailand. I traveled to Thailand for plastic-reconstructive surgery because it was too expensive in the United States, and American insurance companies would not cover the cost of the procedure because they viewed it as an elective surgery. Before going to Thailand, I did months of research on Thai doctors and hospitals in my price range, and thought I had made the right decision until after the surgery, when Dr. Kamol Panritum of the MtF Easthetic Surgery Center, took off the bandages from my face.

Unfortunately, this was only the beginning of my Thailand nightmare. After the doctor refused to refund my money, or pay to have the damage he had done to my face fixed by another doctor, or do the surgery over again himself; I attempted to report the doctor to government and professional medical associations to no avail. I was completely ignored by the Thailand Medical Council, the Thailand College of Surgeons, and the Medical Association of Thailand. I wrote a formal complaint to the hospital were the surgery was performed (Piavate Hospital of Bangkok) and it was ignored.

Even the attorney I attempted to hire, just gave me a run around for several weeks promising to take action against the doctor and never doing so. He initially was very eager to take my case, but shortly after doing so, he not only lost interest in the case, but became an apologist for the doctor. This appeared to have everything to do with me being a foreigner, attempting to take legal action against a wealthy and influential Thai plastic surgeon.

I later discovered that there are extremely few successful medical malpractice cases against medical doctors in Thailand that result in a cash award. Currently, there are only about 60 outstanding medical malpractice case on file with the Medical Council of Thailand for the entire country, and this number of cases is being pointed to by Thai Medical Council authorities as being unacceptably large.

It appears that if something goes wrong with a medical procedure in Thailand, and your are a foreigner, you have few, if any options of redress, and are completely at the mercy of the doctor. Thai attorneys will gladly take your case; and certainly your money, but what is uncertain, is if they will do anything more than take your money. These attorneys certainly must be aware of how few of these cases ever succeed, but there are many attorneys in Thailand that claim they do medical malpractice work.

Medical tourism is rapidly becoming more popular in America, and more Americans are traveling to Thailand to seek potentially dangerous, and risky medical procedures. I, as an American medical tourist to Thailand, am one of many Americans that have chosen this option, and the numbers are growing very rapidly. It seems to me, that the American Embassy should take a more proactive posture, in guarding, protecting, and informing its people of the very real dangers in seeking complicated medical procedure in Thailand, and of the truth about the practical limits to legal redress, if something goes wrong.

If the United States Embassy can publish alerts, warnings, and advice on teaching English in Thailand on its website, it certainly could do a better job addressing the dangers of Medical Tourism in Thailand. Further, the Thai government should be made aware of the increase concern that the United States government has about the exposure of its citizens to the dangers and limitations of Thai medical practice, and the limits of the legal system in Thailand to redress issues of medical malpractice. Americans are being harmed at ever increasing numbers.

If you have any information concerning private and government organizations in Thailand that I should contact in my attempt to hold this doctor accountable for the damage he has done to my face and life, I would much appreciate it. Please respond to this E-mail as soon as possible, by writing me at: HeatherTascal@yahoo.com. Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,
Heather Tascal

Posted
10-Feb-2007 20:18
by: callippo

Posts:  6,135
Registered:  12/07/04

1

Quote

As an American, I have been scared, mutilated, and disfigured by offshore plastic surgery in Thailand.


while I'm sympathetic to what happened to the guy, does he really think that Germans, Japanese, or Australians, for example, would have been any less 'scarred, mutilated, and disfigured' than an American would ?

Posted
10-Feb-2007 21:54
by: welcometolos

Posts:  126
Registered:  23/06/06

2

"I did months of research on Thai doctors and hospitals in my price range"

"I later discovered that there are extremely few successful medical malpractice cases against medical doctors in Thailand "

Well you should have done more research before going under the knife in a foreign country.

There are countless thousands of people who have successfully been treated in Thai hospitals. Sorry to sound heartless but if you must go in for plastic surgery you must also accept the risks involved. I am very sorry you had a bad experience but "caveat emptor" prevails.

Thailand does not need to be deluged by USA style legal actions.

Posted
10-Feb-2007 22:34
by: bwanabrad

Posts:  99
Registered:  19/10/03

3

OP - there is only one way this sort of malpractice will ever be adressed, and that is if it is brought to the attention of the public on a wide scale. Agitate like crazy. lf they won't listen to reason and a decent lawyer, then get the media involved. threats of an expose by a well known tabloid TV program such as 60 minutes, might work more wonders, than consulates and embassies. They are often more attuned to local sensibilities and not wanting to upset their own apple cart, than in looking after the rights and interests of their own citizens.

Also contact the Bangkok Post and the Nation, the two English language newspapers in Bkk and see if they are interested in publicizing your story. l know l will be cutting and pasting this story to put up on a website in my own country, to warn any potential medical toursits against coming here, or using that particular doctor. This is a growing trade in Thailand, but the consummer must have some safeguards. There are some foreign lawyers working in Bangkok see if you can find one of them to talk to and take your case.

lf this doctor won't accept his responsibilities one way, he should be made to look at the costs involved in other ways.

Posted
11-Feb-2007 00:08
by: mozzies

Posts:  1,731
Registered:  25/02/05

4

you should have known one of the reasons medical services in the united states is expensive is because of malpractive law suits. the doctors are accountable and will have to pay up when taken to court. a major part of their expenses is to pay a malpractive insurance. did you expect the same accountability from a thai doctor when you paid 1/10 of the price as in the US?

Posted
11-Feb-2007 00:14
by: angeldust

Posts:  60
Registered:  28/03/01

5

i do feel sorry for you. terrible experience to go through. all kinds of surgery is not without its associated risks, but in retrospect, when you have no recourse, then the risks should really outweigh the other considerations; however i do understand that you felt confident enough with the research that you conducted to go ahead despite the element of risk involved. good luck with your attempts to make this surgeon accountable. i suspect it will be very difficult for you to get very far through any legal channels so perhaps #3's suggestion about bringing negative publicity to this guy and the hospital would be a good way to illicit a response and to also provide a warning to others. good luck in your quest.

if you can't be good - be good at it!

Posted
18-Sep-2008 17:28
by: nampung

Posts:  3
Registered:  18/09/08

6

You may want to have a look at Thailand's new Consumer Protection law which makes it easier for victims of medical malpractice to file legal actions against doctors and health service providers in Thailand. Apparently many doctors are worried about it. There is also an article just posted on the Internet that looks at medical tourism from a legal perspective: Medical Tourism Thailand

Posted
02-Nov-2009 17:53
by: teenutty

Posts:  34
Registered:  07/02/09

7

Actually, I have had two plastic surgery procedures in thailand and they were excellent!!!! Took a lot better care of me than the in the US. In the US, it is normal to discharge a patient and send them home same day as the surgery. Not in Thailand.

I have also all my travel vaccinations and yearly medical check ups there and had better care there than in the US. The hospital in Thailand was using more advanced breast cancer screening methods than what was currently been practiced in the US.

On top of this, I have been treated in Thailand for a resistant amoebic dysentary I had from India.

I can not speak highly enough for the care I received there.

Your Recent Threads

 
RSS Subscribe to all

Announcements

  1. Website speed - Facebook...

    Posted By: VenessaP -- 07-Oct-2009 16:30

 
ADVERTISEMENT

Popular Travel Interests

 

Thailand: Destination information

The Kingdom of Thailand draws more visitors than any other country in southeast Asia with its irresistible combination of breathtaking natural beauty, inspiring temples, renowned hospitality, robust c...more »

See » | Map »

 
Thumb

Thailand Travel Guide

Thailand blends the exotic with modern convenience: Bangkok is a gleaming city with a robust traditional...buy it »

 
 

Booking hotels is simple with Lonely Planet. See our reviewed and recommended hotels and book online.