Great fit, cozy... happy hands!
I rated these "excellent" for comfort and overall, but "good" for durability and quality only because I've used them once and don't know how they'll stand in the long run. But they will get a LOT of use this winter! These were purchased as a "maybe" for Mt. Rainier, where glove combinations I had worn previously were okay but not ideal. These gloves kept my hands cozy in camp when a liner alone wouldn't quite cut it, and I can see them comfortably layered under an appropriately sized shell mitten in the winter. The fabric is soft inside and the outside held up without pilling. I found the medium to be a comfortable, non-constricting fit, and agree with the suggestions to order up a size if you're on the cusp. I'm usually a small, and the medium fit my finger length without bulk elsewhere - I truly have a "like a glove" fit, with excellent dexterity as advertised. I did not experience any discomfort with internal seams, and love the grips and tabs. It was also a plus that I could get this in a color other than black!

Nice Gloves
The gloves fit very well and they're comfortable. Love the plum/purple color. Looks like they'll hold up well but since I just got them I guess time will tell.

best gloves I've found
Love these gloves-I bought the eggplant color for a trip to Alaska last summer and not only were they the right amount of warmth, but also fit well and were not scratchy. I had to recently buy the black as they worked so well. I'm 5'2" 110lb. and have found gloves hard to find that maintain hand dexterity by fitting well. ( The women's small was perfect for me.)

Best every day glove in the business
I love these gloves for general purpose driving, errands, etc., down to about 20F. They have a great blend of practicality and aesthetics. The pull-on loop, the non-stick sections, the comfy texture - can't say enough about them. Bought a pair for my husband last month and he, too, is now a convert.

Great gloves
I was really excited about these gloves. I got them in a size small, which was too small for my hands. My hand measures exactly 6.5 inches, which classifies as a small. But since the inseam in tucked inward it makes the gloves smaller. They were really tight around my fingers. I had to return them for a bigger size. I guess order up if you are right on the cusp of the sizes.